Arson charge filed
CLAY TWP — A guilty conscience got the best of a Butler woman and led to her confession of a crime that happened nearly four years ago, state police said.
Danialle Lynn Digiacomo, 26, allegedly admitted she deliberately set fire in 2009 to a ranch-style home in Clay Township where she lived.
Her then live-in boyfriend, 32-year-old Shane Whipkey, suffered burns to his hands trying to put out the blaze.
The fire destroyed the house and resulted in an insurance payout of more than $165,000, according to court documents.
Chief Reid Campbell of the West Sunbury Volunteer Fire Department always believed the blaze was suspicious but investigators never could prove it.
And after so much time had passed, Campbell never believed a confession would apparently prove him right.
“That was a surprise,” he acknowledged Tuesday.
Police on Friday charged Digiacomo with arson, criminal mischief and reckless endangerment.
Trooper Luke Nelson, a deputy fire marshal, filed the case nearly two months after Digiacomo’s confession.
In charging documents, Nelson said Digiacomo on March 25 “unexpectedly and voluntarily” showed up at the police barracks in Butler Township and admitted she set the fire at 110 Filer Lane on June 29, 2009.
“It was totally out of the blue,” Nelson told the Butler Eagle this morning.
She claimed she ignited a sofa bed in the living room with a cigarette lighter. She also provided police with a motive, documents said.
“(Digiacomo) explained that she no longer wished to live at the residence due to its poor condition and inconvenient location to the city of Butler, for food and drugs,” according to a police affidavit.
However, she claimed she was “contractually and emotionally obligated to stay.”
Whipkey’s mother, Bonnie Sadek of Florida, owned the house.
When the fire struck, Digiacomo’s boyfriend apparently thought he had accidentally set it.
Campbell recalled that Whipkey had told investigators that he been making a brass ring in the living room with a hand drill when he heard a pop.
Whipkey suspected the noise may have been the drill’s battery pack exploding, officials said. Shortly after, he noticed the corner of the couch was on fire.
He said he tried to put out the fire with his hands but it quickly spread to the wall. That’s when Whipkey said he ran outside yelling for help.
He suffered minor burns to his hands. No one else was injured.
Then state police fire marshal Cpl. Jeff Crede investigated the fire but was unable to rule where or how it started. The insurance company’s own fire investigator also was unable to come up with a cause.
Digiacomo at the time told Crede that she had no knowledge of how the fire started. She kept to that story for 45 months.
But on March 25, police said, she delivered her confession, which was audio and video recorded.
During the interview, she told police that she set the fire without warning Whipkey what she did. Afterward, she walked away from the house, taking her dog.
Documents disclosed that Sadek received $165,547 from Homesite Insurance for the loss of her home. She had the house torn down following the fire.
The Butler Eagle could not reach Digiacomo for comment.
Butler County Court records showed she is awaiting sentencing in an unrelated theft case that Butler police filed in November.
