Muddy Creek race ends in dead heat
MUDDY CREEK TWP — For the time being, one primary race remains too close to call.
Still in doubt is who captured the Republican nomination Tuesday for township supervisor. The contest ended in a tie.
Incumbent Rick Saunders and challenger Michael Hart each received 58 votes, according to unofficial results from the Butler County Elections Bureau.
“I knew it would be close,” Hart said. “But maybe not his close.”
Hart was well aware of the dead heat when reached for comment. Saunders, not so much.
Contacted at his home at 10 p.m., he was unaware of the ballot deadlock.
“I wasn’t following it,” he said of the race. “I have to get up early for work.”
Saunders, who is running for a second term, is an equipment operator for the state Department of Transportation.
He didn’t seem particularly concerned about the tie, either.
“Whatever it is,” Saunders said, “we’ll battle it out later.”
Hart, who is running his first campaign for office, is an engineer for Thermo Fisher Scientific in Robinson Township, Allegheny County.
The political newcomer said he decided to seek office because he wants to maintain the status quo in the township.
For example, he said he opposes any efforts to bring public sewer or a building code to Muddy Creek.
“I want to preserve the rural character of the township,” Hart said. “That’s the reason I moved up here.”
The board’s vice chairman, Saunders, defeated Christopher Galbreath by a more than 2-to-1 margin in the GOP primary in 2007.
Later in the fall, Saunders beat his Democratic rival by a nearly 2-to-1 advantage.
Shari Brewer, the county’s director of election, said that the apparent Saunders-Hart tie could be broken once the votes are recounted.
Should the tie remain once the final tally is certified, the candidates will cast lots at the election office to determine the winner.
There were no Democratic candidates for supervisor on the primary ballot.
