Site last updated: Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Suspect faces trial

Scott Black
He's accused of stabbing deaths

TIONESTA, Forest County — The Butler man charged with fatally stabbing his former fiancee and her new boyfriend will face a trial.

That was the ruling of Forest County District Judge George F. Gregory on Tuesday at the preliminary hearing of 38-year-old Scott A. Black.

One victim’s daughter, the Forest County coroner and the state trooper leading the investigation testified at the 90-minute hearing.

Police have charged Black with killing Marcelle I. Edwards, 42, and Donald L. Shay, 43, of Leechburg, Armstrong County, who had just moved in with Edwards at her mobile home near Tionesta.

Trooper Jason Wagner’s testimony revealed that Black had a number of minor injuries, including cuts and bruises, as well as apparent bloodstains on his pants, when he was arrested several hours after the crime occurred. Wagner also testified that a weapon was recovered inside the mobile home.

“It was a knife, a wood grain handle with two screws in it. It was a straight-blade knife,” Wagner said, adding “there was blood on the blade.”

He said the knife is being analyzed by investigators as is Black’s clothing.

Black sat quietly throughout the hearing, rarely moving in his seat or whispering with Forest County Public Defender Todd Woodin.

Black remains in Warren County Jail without bail on two counts each of homicide and aggravated assault, as well as one count each of burglary and possessing an instrument of crime.

Edwards’ 15-year-old daughter, the lone witness from the night of the April 27 slayings, said Black “acted insane” during two visits that night to Edwards’ mobile home on Holly Acres Road in Green Township, about 7 miles east of Tionesta.

She claimed that an apparently intoxicated Black, who knew Edwards kept a handgun in her dresser “under lock and key,” taunted “shoot me, shoot me, go ahead.”

Edwards’ daughter also testified that before the night of the murders, she had never seen Black threaten violence or act violently or erratically.

“He acted insane (that night),” she testified.

The girl confirmed in her testimony that she was sleeping on the living room couch when she awoke to find Shay struggling with Black. When Black hit her mother, she stepped in and hit Black, causing him to fall to the floor, the girl testified.

“I tried to stop him from being aggressive. (Shay) was holding him back and I could tell he was getting tired,” she testified.

When Woodin asked if Black was intoxicated, the girl replied, “(Black) was mean, but he wasn’t falling over. He wasn’t drunk enough not to fight.”

Edwards’ daughter also reiterated that she’d seen Black holding a knife before she ran to her grandmother’s house nearby. The grandmother’s 911 call reached the Venango County 911 center at 1:11 a.m., and troopers arrived on the scene at 1:21 a.m., Wagner testified.

Forest County Coroner Norman J. Wimer testified that autopsies were done on both Shay and Edwards on April 28 by forensic pathologist Eric Vey.

Though Vey’s official autopsy report is yet to be released, Wimer testified that both deaths have been ruled homicides.

Wimer also testified that Shay died of 20 stab wounds to the torso, most of them in his back, while Edwards died of a single stab wound to the front of her neck, though she had what appeared to be defensive wounds on her left arm and face.

After the crime and during the manhunt for Black, Judge Gregory issued police a series of warrants to search Edwards’ home, and Black’s camper, truck and clothing. Black was captured when police spotted him in neighboring Kingsley Township, not far from where he kept a pop-up camper trailer.

Wagner testified that, at the time of Black’s arrest, Black had small cuts near his right eye and on both wrists, as well as bruising on his shin and neck. Responding to questions from Woodin, Wagner said Black was not observed after his arrest to see if new bruises appeared.

Wagner also said two knife sheaths were recovered, one near Holly Acres Road and another on the ground near Black’s trailer.

More than one knife may have been involved in the crime as Wagner’s description of the straight-bladed knife that was collected from the trailer conflicts with the “black-handled knife with a curved blade” described by Edwards’ daughter in court documents.

Neither Woodin nor Forest County District Attorney Elizabeth Ziegler said if a decision has been made whether to seek the death penalty against Black, or if Black will be assigned an attorney qualified to try a capital case.

Woodin, Forest County’s lone public defender, is not death penalty qualified.

In Pennsylvania, a district attorney usually files a notice of intent to seek the death penalty at the defendant’s formal arraignment.

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS