County looks to reduce Sunnyview's deficit
BUTLER TWP — Butler County officials want to open a union contract with workers at the Sunnyview Nursing and Rehabilitation Center to reduce the facility’s deficit.
County solicitor Mike English said at the Sunnyview board meeting Thursday that steps already have been taken to reduce costs at the nursing home, but more needs to be done.
“The situation is so dire, we can only go so far,” English said about doing things other than renegotiating a contract.
Sunnyview is expected to lose $1.5 million this year. However, $450,000 of that is for a balloon payment on a 30-year bond that paid for renovations in the 1980s.
The nursing home ended 2012 more than $800,000 in the red. Sunnyview’s net deficit includes such expenses as building depreciation and indirect costs.
Tamara Lefcowitz, business agent for SEIU Healthcare, a division of the Service Employees International Union, said opening a contract should be the last option.
“We need to work together,” she said.
Under a four-year pact that ends Dec. 31, 2014, roughly 200 Sunnyview workers receive a 3 percent pay hike each year. The salary range for those employees is $25,000 to $43,000.
The contract covers licensed practical nurses and nurse’s aides. The 13 registered nurses at Sunnyview belong to another union.
As with other county employees, Sunnyview workers pay a portion of their health care benefits with a 1.5 percent paycheck deduction.
English pressed Lefcowitz on whether the union is willing to reopen the contract. She said a meeting of the union membership would have to occur before a stance could be taken.
“If I don’t have the support of 200 people, I can’t do anything,” Lefcowitz said.
She said that meeting should be scheduled this month.
Lefcowitz said she is disappointed the county made the request to reopen the contract.
She recalled the union receiving a similar letter a couple years ago from Beaver County, where a real estate broker was hired to market the county’s Friendship Ridge Nursing Home for a possible sale.
“We can prevent this,” Lefcowitz said of the possibility of selling Sunnyview.
She said the quality of care decreases when county-owned nursing homes are privatized.
“They tend to be bottom-feeder companies,” Lefcowitz said.
But she conceded the trend statewide is to private nursing homes.
“The trend in this state is to unload nursing homes,” Lefcowitz said.
Commissioner Jim Eckstein said another way the county could save money at Sunnyview is to increase the health care contribution from management.
“I think change should start at the top,” he said.
Eckstein said people working in the private medical field pay as much as 30 percent for their insurance.
He said his fellow commissioners did not support his idea.
“I got nowhere with this,” he said. “I got rejected for this issue.”
Commissioner Bill McCarrier, board chairman, refuted Eckstein’s comments.
“Jim, you didn’t get rejected,” McCarrier said.
McCarrier said the commissioners previously discussed the pros and cons of taking such a step.
McCarrier pointed out those with higher salaries already pay more than those lower on the pay scale.
“The more you make, the more you’re paying in Butler County,” he said.
Eckstein vowed to make a motion later to increase nonunion employees’ contribution from the current 1.5 percent.
