Site last updated: Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Jury commissioner posts in county may be eliminated

Butler County may lose its jury commissioners after all.

County Commissioner Dale Pinkerton on Wednesday proposed eliminating the two part-time jobs now that Gov. Tom Corbett signed a new law enabling that to occur.

Under Act 4 of 2013, which the Legislature passed in April, the elected posts can be cut even during an election year.

Pinkerton said he would make a motion at the May 22 meeting to remove the posts to save the county $65,000 annually in salaries and benefits.

“People put me here to save the county money,” he said.

Jury commissioners select random lists of prospective jurors to serve at civil and criminal trials.

Pinkerton said the workload for the jury commissioners has dropped over the years. He said between questionnaires and summons for prospective jurors, the jury commissioners handle less than 750 mailings a month.

No matter what the commissioners do, there still will be a primary race for the Republican jury commissioner seat.

Incumbent Jon Galante is running against Pat Stirling. Democrat Jury Commissioner Clinton Bonetti has no opponent.

If the commissioners abolish the posts, Bonetti and the Republican nominee would not be on the November ballot. The jury commissioners would serve out the remainder of 2013.

Pinkerton reiterated that county court administration can handle the tasks currently performed by jury commissioners.

Tom Holman, deputy court administrator, said in an interview court staff could absorb the work.

“We are prepared to respond to what the commissioners want to do,” Holman said.

Commissioner Jim Eckstein opposed the job elimination, saying court administration may have too many employees if it can handle the additional duties.

“Then he ought to get rid of somebody,” Eckstein said about President Judge Thomas Doerr.

The commissioners in November opted to keep jury commissioners in the county. Commissioner Bill McCarrier sided with Eckstein then.

McCarrier said on Wednesday he may reconsider that vote.

“This is a tough decision,” he said.

Larry Thompson, a former jury commissioner and president of the Pennsylvania State Association of Jury Commissioners, chided Pinkerton for pushing for the change.

Thompson said in places such as Allegheny County, where a judge hired her own relatives to work in the court system, abuse occurs.

“There’s no light shining on that system,” he said.

Thompson maintains jury commissioners must remain elected seats.

Pinkerton said Thompson’s example wasn’t valid.

“Allegheny County has nothing to do with Butler County,” Pinkerton said.

Holman said in the interview Butler County court policy is judges cannot hire their own relatives.

He pointed out the possible elimination of jury commissioners doesn’t alter Doerr’s authority in dealing with appointed positions.

“He can hire anyone he wants, anytime he wants,” Holman said.

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS