SR board votes to close Har-Mer
SLIPPERY ROCK TWP — The Slippery Rock School Board Monday voted to close Har-Mer Elementary School in Harrisville, effective this fall.
The 99 students and at least 11 incoming kindergarten students will be split between Moraine and Slippery Rock elementary schools. Additional class sections will be added at Slippery Rock Elementary to keep class sizes manageable, according to Superintendent Kathy Nogay.
“Because we’ve had 17 retirements, no one will be furloughed by this change,” she said.
“Those staff can be reassigned as most have multiple certifications (beyond elementary education).”
The district now must begin notifying staff, students and the Pennsylvania Department of Education of its plans to close the school, she said, giving at least 60 days notice before classes begin in September.
The closure, which has been discussed for years as a cost-cutting measure and as a response to declining enrollment at Har-Mer, did not come easily.
The board approved the move by a 6 to 2 vote, following more than an hour of discussion. Board Vice President Ken Speer and board member Dave Hutner voted against the closure. Board member Mark Mraz was absent.
Both Speer and Hutner suggested delaying the closure, if not the vote, a year to give students, staff and parents ample opportunity to craft a “transition plan” dealing with the closure.
“I’m seriously concerned we may not get this right (given the short timeline before classes begin),” Speer said.
“It’s not that I want to keep Har-Mer open, necessarily. I just want a more well defined transition plan and time to discuss the details further.”
About 20 parents and teachers from Har-Mer were at the meeting, hoping to see the school remain open, including Maggie Stoughton, who herself attended Har-Mer and has a son who was to attend kindergarten there.
“Fiscal responsibility goes beyond just making cuts,” Stoughton said, handing the board a petition with 500 signatures opposing the closure.
“We see a lot of social and educational benefits to (keeping Har-Mer open). Har-Mer is the only school in the Slippery Rock School District that passed its annual state Adequate Yearly Progress (AYP) review.”
Bobbie Jo Combs of Harrisville said she and her family moved from Butler five years ago partly because of Har-Mer, which two of her daughters have passed through, with a third headed to kindergarten in the fall.
“Now, our children will be shipped to Slippery Rock Elementary,” she said, saying they will have to endure a 45-minute bus ride to and from school each day.
Before the vote, Nogay said she was not aware of the exact bus drive times, considering those details would not be examined until the board approved closure.
Although Stoughton and Combs touted small class sizes as one of Har-Mer’s best features, board member Greg Angerett responded saying that because of additional sections of each grade being added, class sizes at Moraine and Slippery Rock elementary schools actually will shrink.
Board member Diana Wolak said, “I’m hoping parents will understand, it’s not ‘you versus us.’ We all want what is best for the students. We have two great groups of parents between Slippery Rock elementary and Har-Mer. Imagine what those two groups can accomplish working together.”
She said delaying the vote further would only heighten a sense of confrontation.
Nogay said the vote on Har-Mer needed to happen sooner rather than later for budget reasons.
“With 17 retirements, I can’t build a budget or do staffing without knowing what’s happening at Har-Mer,” she said.
Board members Polly Shaw and Kirby Lotz were adamant that closing Har-Mer was the right action to take, and that closure would not have a profound effect on students.
“This isn’t the first time we’ve closed a school,” Shaw said, adding that students may move buildings, but will remain with their friends. “It’s not a big deal.”
She said her own children experienced no ill effects when their elementary education was transferred to Moraine Elementary after the former Portersville Elementary closed.
Lotz said that despite its sentimental value, Har-Mer is ultimately just a building.
“(The school board) is not as important as we sometimes think we are,” he said.
“No matter what building these kids are in, the ones who have parental support, that emphasis on education at home, those will be the ones who most often succeed, regardless of where.”
Stoughton disagreed, saying she is aware of at least six families who will move to the Grove City School District, apply to Grove City Christian Academy or pursue cyber school instead of remaining in Slippery Rock School District.
