Restitution figure disputed
A Fairview Township man, who pleaded guilty to damaging his home after the bank foreclosed, but before it took ownership of the house, is disputing his $36,364 restitution bill.
Gary Ellenberger, 50, acknowledges removing a swimming pool and a carport that he used as a picnic shelter from the 362 Cherry Road property. But he alleges he didn’t do the massive vandalism described inside the property and shouldn’t have to pay for it.
An insurance adjuster on Tuesday told Butler County Judge William Shaffer that the home’s toilet and bathtub were missing. There were hammer holes in the walls and paint splattered throughout the house. In one place, paneling was taken down so that insulation could be removed.
Prosecutors are seeking $36,000 in restitution.
Assistant District Attorney Ben Simon explained to the judge that before the damage, the property was appraised twice: at $75,000 in 2011 and $50,000 in 2010.
After the damage in late 2011, the property was appraised at $14,000, including its two-acre lot.
The restitution tally, Simon said, is the difference between the final appraisal and the lower of the two initial estimates.
Simon pointed out that the bank was forgoing the value of the mortgage. Initially, the property was mortgaged at $102,000 in 2006, and it still had an outstanding balance of $95,000 when the bank took it back at an appraised value of $14,000.
From the damage, the insurance company reimbursed the bank for nearly $7,000 in damage that was deemed vandalism and not theft. The insurance company is asking that Ellenberger be ordered to repay that money to it as well as the outstanding money owed the bank.
But Ellenberger argued that his financial responsibility should be lower because he did not cause all of the damage. Specifically, he doesn’t think he should be responsible for nearly $7,000 because he claims he did not vandalize the property.
Ellenberger testified during the Tuesday hearing that he removed the swimming pool because “it was junk” and had rotted through. He acknowledged removing the tin carport, which his family used as a picnic shelter, down to the foundation.
“I did not know what I was allowed to take and not allowed to take,” Ellenberger told the judge.
But when it comes to the other allegations, Ellenberger said he only pleaded guilty to a charge of criminal mischief because his wife pleaded guilty in the case while he was in jail. And they did not have money to fight the case.
Court records say Ellenberger, who was sentenced to serve five years probation for the damage to the house, was incarcerated on an unrelated drunken driving conviction.
Court records indicate Christina Ellenberger, 46, also pleaded guilty to criminal mischief and was sentenced to five years probation.
Butler County Judge William Shaffer listened to Ellenberger’s argument about the amount of restitution and will rule later.
