Site last updated: Wednesday, November 18, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Owner raises reward in fire

Lorena Adams stands at the remains of the Cherry Township home she was remodeling before it burned in 2010. Though not officially declared arson, Adams believes the fire was intentionally set.

CHERRY TWP — Lorena Adams refuses to forget her house at 170 Coaltowne Road.

Until Feb. 5, 2010, the little country house was both her past and her future.

Homestead to her maternal grandparents since the 1930s, the 1½ story stone house was bought by Adams, 38, and she was nearly finished remodeling it when it burned.

Although the devastating fire was never officially ruled arson, investigators agree with Adams' assessment: “The house didn't just catch fire by itself.”

Adams, who did not have insurance on the home, initially offered a $1,000 reward for tips leading to the arrest and conviction of the person responsible for starting the fire.

But as the seasons changed without resolution and people urged Adams to just wipe it out of her mind, her resolution grew stronger.

She's now increasing the reward to $5,000.

“I'm not giving up,” Adams said.

State Police Trooper Luke Nelson, who became the state police fire investigator since the time of this fire, said he believes this case is solvable. It's possible, Nelson said, that the right tip from the right person could change the ruling to arson, solidify a suspect and close this case.

“I'd welcome all information,” Nelson said.

Nelson said a lot of circumstantial evidence has been collected, and a tip could tie it all together.

Specifically, investigators found near the fire a stolen car stuck in the snow, but still running. The car's trunk was open, and inside were electrical motors apparently taken from the home before it burned.

“And a case of 80 light bulbs that had been on the kitchen counter,” Adams said. “I never got that.”

Despite the heavy inference, the house fire still is listed as having an “undetermined cause.” Nelson explained that to issue an arson finding, investigators must pinpoint the cause of ignition. In this case, Nelson said the damage was so overwhelming that there was not enough left to make that call for sure.

“We are 99.9 percent sure it's arson,” Nelson said.

Since that time, the only thing on the 3-acre lot is some burned out rubble, both a heartache and headache to Adams.

Adams had taken out a $25,000 loan to improve the property. She used the loan to replace the roof, electrical system, doors and windows.

“Now,” Adams said. “Every month on the 15th I pay on the loan for something I don't have anymore. The bank doesn't care that the house isn't there.”

Adams, who is raising her family in the Callery area, said her plan was to remodel the Cherry Township home, then spend weekends there until her two stepsons graduated from high school. Then, the family would move there entirely.

“We wanted a home in the country,” she said, noting that she grew up only about a quarter mile away from the home and visited her grandparents there just about daily.

“I practically grew up in that house,” she said.

Adams said her grandparents bought the home in the 1930s and had made additions and improvements. Adams said her grandfather harvested stone from the property and chiseled it by hand to create the facade.

At the time of the fire, many of her grandparents' personal items — including Christmas decorations — still were in the home.

“That house meant a lot to me,” she said. “I can't 'just forget it' like people keep telling me.”

Anyone with information should call state police at 724-284-8100.

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS