Site last updated: Thursday, November 19, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

State tries to combat ash borer

Destructive pest invaded Pa. in 2007

While no one is celebrating the upcoming sixth anniversary of the emerald ash borer’s arrival in Pennsylvania, steps are being taken to combat the destructive pest as it chews its way through the state.

By the time the tiny green beetle made its June 2007 Pennsylvania debut in a young ash tree in Cranberry Township, the species had already destroyed 20 million ash trees in several states. The species has now invaded 29 of Pennsylvania’s 67 counties.

The ash borer entered North America in southeastern Michigan in 2002 by stowing away in shipping liners from Southeast Asia, where it is an indigenous species. The bug can destroy an ash tree in three years after larvae laid under the bark disrupts the tree’s ability to transport water and nutrients throughout the tree.

Sven-Erik Spichiger, entomology program manager at the state Department of Agriculture, said the borer is on track to cause a predicted $760 million in ash tree damage to Pennsylvania’s 3 million ash trees.

“When you are predicting 99.99 percent mortality and all the trees die (in the affected counties), yes, it has been devastating,” Spichiger said.

He said ash wood is traditionally used to make baseball bats and tool handles, and factories in northern Pennsylvania that manufacture blanks for tool handles, as well as the Louisville Slugger company, are in danger.

“For them, this is not an insignificant loss,” Spichiger said. “They are going to really start feeling the impact.”

In Cranberry Township, Graham Park and Cranberry Highlands Golf Course have seen their ash trees decimated by the emerald ash borer, according to Hoping Liu, state Department of Conservation and Natural Resources forest entomologist.

He said the golf course lost the trees even though the trees were treated with chemicals.

Spichiger and Liu both stressed the quarantine requirements instituted when the emerald ash borer invaded townships surrounding Cranberry should still be followed to slow the borer’s spread. Those requirements prohibit the transport of firewood, mulch or other untreated hardwood between counties.

Tim Corace, owner of Falling Timber Tree Service in Saxonburg, said he has removed more than 100 ash trees due to the destructive power of the borer.

Corace said the spate of ash-tree removal calls began about two years ago and continue today.

“Property owners say one year they have leaves and look perfectly healthy, and the next year the bark’s off and there are no leaves on them,” Corace said.

Telltale tiny holes on the trees are the mark of the borer, Corace said.

He said he saves the wood for firewood or mulches it up for compost, but he never moves it out of Butler County.

“We try to recycle them as much as we can,” Corace said.

One customer had more than 70 ash trees on his property, and Corace has removed about 15 so far.

“Eventually, we’ll probably take them all out,” he said.

Corace said the emerald ash borer is the worst blight on trees he has seen in his career. Other diseases and infestations of the past, he said, have been patchy and some trees have survived.

“It seems like everyone (with ash trees) has it,” he said.

Spichiger said chemical treatments, which are labor intensive and expensive, can be successful in certain situations.

“If you have a 100-year-old ash tree with historical value, it may be worth the expense to protect it,” Spichiger said. “But for an ash stand with 40 to 50 trees, it’s not worth it.”

Liu is in charge of a state program that saw the release of three species of tiny, stingless wasps in 2011.

In Southeast Asia, the wasps help keep the borer’s population under control. One species attacks the borer’s eggs, while the other two attack its larva.

The wasps were released in Pennsylvania in North Park and Deer Lakes Park, both in Allegheny County, and at a game lands in Juniata County.

He said the emerald ash borer is now present in 19 states, and 14 of them have released insects to combat the destructive beetle.

Liu explained that extensive research, including traveling to the emerald ash borer’s native habitat in Asia, was required before the wasps could be released. Scientists also look at whether the wasps bring disease or attack other insects in their new environment.

He said the wasps also attack the two-lined chestnut borer and the bronze birch borer, but they prefer the emerald ash borer.

“And those other borers are pests as well, so it’s no problem,” Liu said.

Once they were deemed safe for release, the wasps were kept under tight oversight by Liu’s department. First, scientists search for signs of the wasps in the spring to determine whether they have survived winter.

Liu reports that two of the three wasp species did survive the snow and cold of their new homes.

“It is very encouraging if you find them alive after one year,” Liu said.

But he said it could take decades for the wasps to have an effect on the emerald ash borer population.

He said the goal of entomologists is to see the U.S. Department of Agriculture mass produce the wasps and distribute them to states at no charge.

More information on the emerald ash borer is available by searching “emerald ash borer” at www.agriculture.state.pa.us.

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS