Site last updated: Thursday, November 19, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Burglary suspect sentenced in plea deal

Butler home targeted in ill-conceived plan

A burglar in an alleged get-rich-quick scheme gone awry will serve up to five years in state prison.

Butler County Judge Tim McCune on Tuesday sentenced Michael A. Chase, 24, of Corry, Erie County, to 30 to 60 months in prison for his role in the accidental home invasion in Butler last year.

City police say Chase and two accomplices on May 14 traveled from Erie to Butler on an ill-conceived plan to break into a house on Miller Avenue.

Stashed in the house, they believed, was a cache of cash left there by a former tenant — a convicted bank robber, according to investigators.

Chase and Robert Cote, 28, of Erie while inmates at the State Correctional Institution at Albion, Erie County, in 2012, learned that the loot from one or more heists was supposedly there for the taking.

A short time after getting out of jail, court documents said, they met up with Dirk Milner, 27, of Erie and the trio drove to Butler to collect the hidden treasure.

However, the jailhouse story proved to be a cruel hoax, police said.

But that wasn’t their only blunder that day. Much to their surprise, the suspects broke into the wrong house.

Instead of the targeted “flop house” used by junkies to get high, Chase and Milner mistakenly busted into Robert and Judy Winrader’s home, police said.

While Cote manned the crew’s getaway car, Chase and Milner, armed with crow bars, intended to rip open walls to get to the imaginary money. Instead, they confronted the Winraders and the couple’s adult son, Scott, who also lived there.

When Scott Winrader tried to stop the suspected burglars, Chase and Milner scuffled briefly with him, before beating a hasty retreat with little more than $10. Moments later, police said, the suspects headed back to Erie. Winrader suffered minor injuries.

It would take several months, but police eventually arrested Chase and Cote. Soon after that, Milner was nabbed.

Chase on April 6 pleaded guilty to charges of conspiracy to commit burglary and simple assault.

In exchange, the Butler County District Attorney’s Office withdrew charges of burglary, robbery, aggravated assault, trespass and criminal mischief.

McCune sentenced Chase in accordance with the plea deal reached between prosecutor Mark Lope and defense attorney Matthew Kalina.

Lope waived the eligibility requirements to allow Chase to be accepted into the state’s Recidivism Risk Reduction Incentive program.

Under that program, nonviolent offenders get the chance to reduce their minimum prison sentences if they successfully complete counseling programs and maintain good-conduct records in prison.

With a total 30-to-60-month sentence, Chase would be eligible to reduce his minimum prison stay to 22 months and 15 days, according to program guidelines.

McCune credited Chase with 7 months and 2 days in the county prison since his arrest Sept. 21.

At his sentencing hearing, Chase, who also has a pending drunken driving case in Erie County Court, apologized to the Winrader family, who did not attend.

“I accept responsibility for my actions,” he told McCune. “I acted out of character on how I usually conduct myself. I’m sorry for the people I harmed. They didn’t deserve it.”

Meanwhile, Cote and Milner are awaiting trial in the case. Both men are charged with burglary, conspiracy to commit burglary, aggravated assault, trespass, simple assault and criminal mischief.

Additionally, Milner is charged with robbery. He is free on $5,000 bail.

Cote, who also has pending cases for drugged driving and simple assault in Erie County Court, is free on $10,000 bail.

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS