Board may cap own time to talk
The Butler County Commissioners are considering limiting the time they’re permitted to speak during public meetings.
Commissioner Bill McCarrier, board chairman, said at Monday’s meeting that commissioner comments should be limited to 10 minutes a person because Commissioner Jim Eckstein takes too long, making repetitive comments “ad nauseam.”
Under current county policy, each of the three commissioners has unlimited time to talk about any topics near the end of a meeting.
Since the three commissioners took office in 2012, Eckstein typically takes longer than his colleagues.
McCarrier said the meetings are taking too long.
“I’m doing this to try and expedite the meetings,” he said.
Eckstein challenged the validity of limiting his time. He said the American Civil Liberties Union told him it would be unlawful to restrict his time to speak.
“That is not legal,” Eckstein said.
County solicitor Mike English said he would research whether there was any court precedent indicating if such a move would be prohibited.
Commissioner Dale Pinkerton agreed with McCarrier that 10 minutes should be sufficient time for Eckstein.
“You have your 10 minutes to talk about what you want,” Pinkerton said.
Eckstein conceded 10 minutes is enough time for him to address most topics, but doesn’t want to be hindered when there are major expenses before the board.
He cited the example of a proposed county office building being constructed next to the government center as an issue requiring more extensive discussion.
Eckstein accused his fellow commissioners of wanting to use a time limit to hinder his commentary and keep information hidden.
“It’s blatant,” Eckstein said.
McCarrier pointed out Eckstein still would have no time restriction to speak when the commissioners are discussing an item on a meeting agenda.
“You’re free to talk as long as you want,” McCarrier said.
Eckstein countered by saying the majority of the board would prevent items from being on the agenda.
McCarrier reminded Eckstein that two commissioners, who comprise a board majority, have the right to set the agenda.
Pinkerton agreed with McCarrier that there were instances when Eckstein’s items were not removed from the agenda.
Another proposed change would be limiting a commissioner’s response to residents speaking during public comment to two minutes.
Eckstein opposed the move, saying he should be entitled to the same three minutes as residents have.
The commissioners currently have no limit on how long they talk when replying to comments made by residents.
Board members for municipalities typically use report periods to discuss business done by committees or boards for which they serve as liaisons.
In the county’s case, the commissioners serve as liaisons to such boards as the Butler County Children and Youth Advisory Board and Butler County Community College.
The county commissioners traditionally have used the report portion of meetings to relay what events, such as a volunteer fire department dinner, they attended.
English confirmed the commissioners are not bound by any legal restrictions on what topics they discuss.
The commissioners on Wednesday are expected to vote on the proposed limits to commissioner reports and commissioner responses to public comment.
