Armed robbery suspect awaits trial
A Butler convenience store clerk testified Monday about facing an armed robber alone at night.
But Joseph Labryer, who was wrapping up his regular night shift at the 7-Eleven on Pillow Street, wasn’t scared.
“I didn’t think it was serious at first, and I said, ‘Are you serious?’”
The tire-iron wielding suspect’s not-so-good disguise only fed the clerk’s skepticism.
“He had a sweat shirt around his face, but it kept falling down,” Labryer said. “I saw his face.”
At the preliminary hearing, Labryer identified 29-year-old Anthony J. Donachy of Jefferson Township as the man who tried to rob him March 14.
District Judge Pete Shaffer later ordered Donachy held for court on a charge of robbery.
Earlier Monday, Donachy was in Butler County Court at an unrelated hearing for violating his probation stemming from a prior conviction.
Donachy’s previous crime was holding up the same store just last year.
After his day in and out of court Monday, Donachy ended back in the Butler County Prison on $75,000 bail.
Labryer recounted at the hearing that he only was several months on the job when he was closing out his shift about 4:30 a.m. March 14 when he heard what he thought was a customer enter the store. But this was no regular customer.
”He had a tire iron,” the clerk said.
The man, dressed in a brown hooded sweat shirt pulled up to hide his face, walked up to the counter.
“I basically stood my ground,” Labryer said.
The suspect slammed the makeshift weapon on the counter.
“He said, ‘Give me the money,’” Labryer testified. “At first, I didn’t think it was real.”
The robber repeated his demand and banged the tire iron a second time. And then a third time.
But when a genuine customer walked in, the suspect “got spooked,” Labryer recalled, and fled.
Two witnesses saw the man drive away in a Ford Ranger pickup truck.
Based on that clue, the clerk’s description and Butler police’s familiarity with Donachy, he soon was arrested at his house.
And soon after that police had a confession and a motive, Patrolman Jeremy Walters testified at the hearing.
“He admitted to the allegation and acknowledged he had relapsed on crack cocaine,” Walters said of Donachy.
The police interview, Walters noted, was audio and videotaped after Donachy had waived his Miranda warnings.
Donachy in August admitted he used a baseball bat to strong-arm another clerk at the same 7-Eleven on Feb. 16, 2012. He made off with $65.
Like last month’s robbery, police needed only several hours to arrest him after the holdup last year.
He eventually pleaded guilty to aggravated assault and theft in the case. Prosecutors dropped other charges of robbery and possession of drug paraphernalia, court records showed.
Donachy was sentenced to 9 to 18 months in the county prison, followed by a year’s probation.
He ended up serving the minimum and was released Oct. 7.
But he was back in court Monday in the 2012 case for a violating his probation in connection with the March 14 robbery.
