Clinton gives OK to drill
CLINTON TWP — The township supervisors on Tuesday voted to allow PennEnergy to drill for natural gas on township property.
The motion passed 2-1, with Mary Zacherl and Jim Halstead voting yes and Ed Boyd voting no.
PennEnergy of Pittsburgh was one of two companies to bid. It offered $3,500 per acre for 5 years with 15 percent post production royalties with a 5 year extension at $5,000 per acre.
PennEnergy will be allowed to do nonsurface drilling on 82 acres in Spring Valley Park and on 13 acres around the township building and equipment grounds.
In addition to PennEnergy, Huntley and Huntley of Monroeville also placed a bid, offering $5,005 per acre for 7 years with 18 percent post production royalties with a 7 year extension at $5,005 per acre.
Of the decision to pick PennEnergy, Halstead said, “You almost have to go with your gut.” He said the choice was difficult and one consideration was which company was most likely to drill.
Initially, all three supervisors abstained from voting because they all had or had connections to the two gas companies. Zacherl and her husband have a lease with Huntley and Huntley, Halstead’s parents have a lease with PennEnergy and Boyd and his wife have a lease in which Huntley and Huntley is involved.
Zacherl read a letter from the township solicitor that said, if all supervisors abstain from a vote and state why they are abstaining, then a second vote may be held where the supervisors are allowed to vote. The motion passed on the second vote.
Boyd said that he chose to vote against the motion because of information he got in March. After the meeting, he declined to be specific about that information.
Before the vote, six township residents spoke in favor of enacting a community rights ordinance banning fracking for Marcellus Shale natural gas until it is proven safe. The residents presented the supervisors with information regarding potential and documented dangers related to fracking.
Sam Edwards said that gas companies say that fracking is safe.
“The data that is rolling in is saying the opposite,” Edwards said.
He said that fracking involves harmful chemicals that could be health concerns.
Dave Douglass said that a gas company representative came to his door and offered him a contract about three years ago. He took the contract to an attorney for advice.
“He said, ‘I would never sign this. This is all in the gas company’s favor,’” Douglass said.
He said that seismic testing recently happened near his property. Since then, he has had his water tested, and it has showed a large amount of methane. He said he has occasionally been able to light his water on fire. He said he is not sure if the testing has anything to do with it.
Douglass said he is not willing to sacrifice health for money. If fracking is proven safe, he said he would support it.
Zacherl thanked the residents for their input and said that supervisors would consider it.
“It definitely is important that you brought it to us,” Zacherl said.
Boyd said, based on the information the residents presented, that he would be more comfortable pushing the vote on the drilling to another meeting.
“I don’t know if it’s the proper thing to deal with at this point in time,” Boyd said.
However, Halstead and Zacherl said that they can take the information into consideration while moving forward.
“It’s been six months,” Zacherl said, noting that the township received the bids in October.
