Defendant fails drug program, gets jail time
Despite pleas from Brett Whitmire’s friends, family and lawyer, a Butler County judge imposed the prison sentence that Whitmire agreed to when he entered the county’s drug treatment program: 4 to 13 years.
Whitmire, 34, of Hilliards faced the stiff sentence because he failed the program. Had he successfully completed it, he likely would have gotten two years of probation.
According to court records, Whitmire entered the program in January 2012 after violating his probation on charges on a 2005 burglary conviction, a 2011 possession of a controlled substance conviction, a 2005 theft conviction and a 2004 receiving stolen property conviction.
While in the program, defendants are assigned individualized rehabilitation goals and are monitored closely by a probation officer and Butler County Judge William Shaffer.
According to Whitmire’s defense lawyer James Paulick, Whitmire made a lot of progress in the program. But 12 days before he was to graduate, Whitmire failed a drug test for the second time and was removed from the program.
Once ousted from drug court, defendants face the stiff prison sentences that they agreed to as part of being accepted into the program.
In this case, Whitmire’s lawyer argued the punishment was unfairly “harsh based on the nature of the crimes.” He stressed that Whitmire has committed no violent crimes and has never been accused of dealing drugs.
The lawyer said Whitmire now has a job and a fiancee who is expecting to deliver his son in a few months.
Both Whitmire’s employer and his father spoke on his behalf. Whitmire also spoke, apologizing for his “past mistakes” and pledging to do better.
But Butler County Judge Timothy McCune, who took over the case because Shaffer recused himself, refused to stray from the sentence Whitmire agreed to in drug court, saying such action would “create chaos” in the drug court program.
McCune said the programs works on a “carrot and a stick” basis and Whitmire was aware of the consequences of failure when he entered the program.
“What else do you want the county to do for Mr. Whitmire? We’ve done all we can,” McCune said. “It’s time to give the state (prison system) a turn.”
