Site last updated: Saturday, November 21, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Homicide hearing delayed

Suspects' lawyers claim the victim was aggressor

KITTANNING — Attorneys for the four men charged in the beating death of a Butler County man say they expect a pending toxicology report to show that their clients were defending themselves from an aggressive victim.

But while waiting for the full autopsy report, including the toxicology section, to be released for 39-year-old James Sullivan of Donegal Township, District Judge James Owen on Wednesday granted a two-week delay in the preliminary hearings for the defendants.

The defense attorneys said outside the Armstrong County Courtroom that they suspected that the toxicology report would show that Sullivan, a Persian Gulf War veteran, was intoxicated by alcohol and possibly drugs.

“We believe (Sullivan) started this fight and things just spiraled out of control almost in a mob-like mentality,” said Michael DeRiso of Pittsburgh, counsel for Anthony M. Bove.

The 18-year-old Bove, his stepfather, Otilio Cosme, 43, both of Ford City, and 32-year-old Keith A. Brison of Kittanning all are charged with a top count of homicide.

The fourth suspect, Dennis A. Rosenberger, 27, of Kittanning is charged with felony assault.

Prosecutors allege that Rosenberger sucker-punched Sullivan about 1:35 a.m. March 17 on Montieth Street in Kittanning.

The punch to the face knocked Sullivan backward, causing his head to hit the pavement, state police said.

Moments later, according to investigators, while the victim lay unconscious with a fractured skull, the other three defendants jumped on and kicked his motionless body.

Sullivan was pronounced dead less than 90 minutes later at ACMH Hospital in East Franklin Township.

An autopsy ruled the manner of death was homicide. A cause of death is pending the final report.

However, Armstrong County District Attorney Scott Andreassi said findings suggest that the lethal injury was a cut on a major vein in the stomach area.

That injury, he said, was from the beating and kicking, not the initial punch.

The deadly confrontation on St. Patrick’s Day weekend followed a night of reveling at the nearby Wick City Saloon.

Shortly before closing time, police said, several fights broke out as patrons spilled out into the street.

Attorneys for the defendants claim that Sullivan instigated the principal fight that night.

Some 75 people — mostly friends and family of Sullivan and the suspects — packed the courtroom Wednesday in anticipation of hearing evidence in the case.

But following a 25-minute closed-door meeting between Andreassi and the four defense attorneys, Judge Owen declared from the bench that the hearing would be continued until April 17.

Moments before that announcement, a county detective escorted Sullivan’s mother and other family members out the back of the courtroom.

The defendants, all wearing bright orange jail fatigues, showed no visible emotion during the brief proceedings.

Afterward, the defense attorneys seemed to offer a glimpse into their legal strategies.

“This is a self-defense case,” said Phillip DiLucente of Pittsburgh, who represents Cosme. “Our clients were walking away and going to their vehicles when they were the ones that were attacked.”

“It’s a case of manslaughter at most,” said James Ecker of Pittsburgh, Brison’s lawyer, “if there’s any case at all.”

He called the pending toxicology results “very important.” DiLucente said they were “imperative” to his case.

“Maybe (Sullivan) had more than alcohol in his system,” DiLucente said. “Maybe that could explain the actions he took that night.”

DeRiso indicated that he, too, suspected Sullivan’s intoxication was at least partially to blame for the events.

“I believe his (blood-alcohol count) was well over the legal limit,” DeRiso said, “and I have reason to believe there were narcotics in his system.”

That belief is rooted in the accounts of some witnesses, he said.

“Beyond that,” DeRiso said, “I don’t think my client contributed to (Sullivan’s) death. I don’t think he kicked the victim.”

But Andreassi scoffed at the other side’s focus on whether Sullivan was drunk.

“The defense seems interested in the toxicology for some reason,” he said. “But that has little or no impact on the case.”

He also dismissed any argument that Sullivan was the aggressor.

“It appears undisputed that James Sullivan was struck and rendered unconscious or near unconscious,” Andreassi said, “and the events that led to his death followed that.”

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS