Board ponders crime checks
BUTLER TWP — Butler School Board members may soon be asked to undergo the same criminal background checks that staff members and school-based contractors do.
New policy language will be introduced at April’s policy committee meeting, said Tom King, the school district solicitor. Board members approved the idea at their March 18 policy meeting when it was suggested by Helene Abramowitz, board vice president.
“(The school board) can have it as a policy, but it would not be something ... that could keep them from holding office,” King said.
Because school board members are elected officials, only the Butler County District Attorney’s office could remove them, King said, although he believes background checks are an admirable idea.
“(It’s saying) we’re not above everyone else,” King said.
Legally, school board members could refuse to submit to the checks. However, King said a board member’s refusal to comply might reflect negatively on him and affect his influence or curtail the activities he might participate in.
The checks include state Act 34 criminal history reports, Act 151 child abuse clearances and the national Act 114 FBI clearances, which requires fingerprinting.
King acknowledged that some elected officials might object to being fingerprinted, but said fingerprinting is increasingly common.
“In today’s world I don’t think it’s an unreasonable provision,” he said.
The school district would pay for the background checks, King said.
Nothing in the state school code requires school board members to undergo background checks, said Steve Robinson, spokesman for the Pennsylvania School Boards Association.
Most commonly, school boards ask persons who have student contact to undergo the checks, Robinson said. Butler does not ask its volunteers to undergo fingerprinting, but does check for criminal histories.
Robinson knew of only one other school district statewide considering background checks for school board members.
The Stroudsburg School Board tabled a measure to require them March 21. In a heated discussion, members asked what would be done with the information and who would have access to it, according to a local news report.
At the state level, the Constitution prohibits a person convicted of “embezzlement of public moneys, bribery, perjury or other infamous crimes” from holding public office, according to Robinson.
Although the state Supreme Court has said felons are ineligible for office, according to Robinson, King said he recalls a felon who served on a Butler County school board at least a decade ago and was not removed from office.
The school code requires only that school board members be at least 18 years old, live in the district for at least a year and “be of good character,” King said.
