Site last updated: Saturday, November 21, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Abbott's mother seeking book deal

Prosecutors: That's why he wants plea withdrawn

Colin Abbott’s mother — a murder mystery writer — is shopping for a book or movie deal about her son.

She doesn’t deny it. And prosecutors are asserting that — not a legal “manifest injustice” — is one of the reasons why the convicted killer is seeking to withdraw his plea to two counts of murder and instead have a trial.

Abbott, a 42-year-old New Jersey man, on Thursday verbally reinforced his earlier, written request to undo the plea arrangement he made with the Butler County District Attorney’s office. Abbott pleaded no contest to third-degree murder in the shooting deaths of his father and stepmother in June 2011.

In exchange for the plea, prosecutors gave up their request for the death penalty and recommended Abbott’s 35-to-80-year prison sentence.

Prosecutors believe Abbott shot and killed Kenneth Abbott, 65, and Celeste Abbott, 55, as part of a plan to erase $2 million in debt to his father and to inherit the couple’s $4 million estate. Investigators found the couple’s remains burned and scattered on their 25-acre Brady Township estate on July 13, 2011.

Claiming he felt pressured into entering a plea deal, Abbott told county Judge William Shaffer on Thursday that if he had 10 days to consider his actions, which he believed he had, he would not have gone through with the sentencing. Abbott noted that he received a “significant report” related to his defense after his sentencing and alleges it constitutes a manifest injustice, which is the legal standard to withdraw a plea after a defendant has been sentenced.

But Assistant District Attorney Ben Simon, opposing Abbott’s request, offered up two other reasons he believes Abbott waged the request, “to create chaos and get a book deal for his mom.”

Simon presented the judge with audio recordings of nine telephone calls Abbott made from the county prison after his sentencing. One is between him and his girlfriend, and the others are between him and his mother, 64-year-old Deborah Buchanan.

“Let’s just see what chaos it starts,” Abbott says to Buchanan, who was the first of Kenneth Abbott’s four wives.

In a different call, Abbott says to his mother, “Even if I end up upstate, it’s a publicity start in the right direction for you. Possibly for a book. Possibly for other things. Ya know? I just want you to get your money back.”

After court, Buchanan, who has owned the publishing company “Deadly Ink” since 2005, confirmed she’s shopping for a book or movie deal.

“I’m talking to people,” said Buchanan, who has traveled from her home in New Jersey to the courthouse every time her son had a court hearing. “His side has not gotten out at all.”

Buchanan said her son is yet to give her a report of what really happened. However, she feels assured of his innocence.

“He didn’t hurt either Kenneth or Celeste,” Buchanan said. “I believe that.”

As a writer of murder-mysteries, Buchanan said it’s been in the back of her mind to write a book since the case began. It’s not written yet, she said, “but I have a lot of notes.”

She said she does not want to self-publish the book, if one’s written.

“In the world of mystery writers that would be a step down from main street publishing,” she said.

Shaffer said he would rule later, in writing on Abbott’s request as well as a related request by Abbott’s defense attorney Wendy Williams who wants to withdraw from the case and have a different attorney appointed to represent Abbott.

More in Local News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS