Review of insurance merger sought
HARRISBURG, — Several consumer groups and a labor union that represents health-care workers want the state to appoint an independent consumer advocate to help review the proposed merger of Pennsylvania's two largest health insurers.
The groups say such an advocate would ensure that consumers' interests are represented as the state Insurance Department considers the possible marriage of Independence Blue Cross and Highmark Inc.
Without a consumer representative who could cross-examine the two nonprofit companies or call expert witnesses at merger hearings — a role similar to the state's utility consumer advocate — the review process will shortchange the public, said Jonathan M. Stein of Community Legal Services of Philadelphia, a nonprofit legal-aid group that is representing the organizations.
"We need to see some real substantial public benefit coming out of this merger, and we don't see it right now," Stein said Thursday.
The groups made their request in a petition filed with acting Insurance Commissioner Joel Ario, but they would like Gov. Ed Rendell to make the appointment, Stein said. They include the Philadelphia Unemployment Project, the Pittsburgh-based Consumer Health Coalition, and the Service Employees International Union state council.
Rendell said he saw no need to appoint a consumer advocate because he and Ario already represent policyholders' interests.
