Site last updated: Sunday, November 15, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Time running out on moving primary

HARRISBURG — The case for an earlier presidential primary in Pennsylvania is straightforward: It would give the state's 7 million Democrats and Republicans more clout in deciding whom the parties nominate for the highest office in the land.

But the arguments against moving up the 2008 primary are many, and the time left to make such a change is quickly passing.

"It's not going to happen," predicted Sen. Jake Corman, R-Centre, chairman of the Senate Republican Policy Committee, which held a hearing on the subject in March. "There was no excitement outside this building for it."

Pennsylvania, traditionally a major presidential battleground in the general election, holds its presidential primary on the fourth Tuesday in April. By that time in 2004, the Democratic contest to decide who would challenge President Bush was virtually over: John Kerry had become the presumptive nominee weeks earlier.

"We are, have been (and) continue to be losing ground" in the state's efforts to influence the nominating process, Rep. Harry A. Readshaw, D-Allegheny, argued before the House State Government Committee last week.

The committee is expected to vote in the coming days on Readshaw's bill to move up the primary by 10 weeks, to the second Tuesday in February.

Gov. Ed Rendell advocates moving the primary up an additional week — to Feb. 5 — for 2008 only. After that, the Democrat said he hopes Congress can agree on a national plan for scheduling presidential primaries in 2012 and thereafter.

"I think that this whole process is a mess," Rendell said last week.

Trouble is, 16 other states — including fellow heavyweights California and New York — have already scheduled 2008 primaries or caucuses on Feb. 5. At least four other states — including Michigan — are considered likely to follow suit.

Ironically, the piling-on will probably undermine the states' common goal of boosting their prominence in the nominating process, one political analyst said.

Because the news media will report the results collectively, "the states are not going to have the influence they thought they were going to have," said Larry Sabato, director of the Center for Politics at the University of Virginia.

"Even California won't get a headline," he said.

There are other, more parochial arguments against changing the date, too.

The Pennsylvania County Commissioners Association pointed out that moving the primary would cause headaches for local officials and state candidates — during the winter holidays, no less — by creating an overlap between postelection tasks, such as certifying the results of the 2007 election, and pre-election responsibilities, such as circulating nominating petitions for the 2008 primary.

"We are now very late in the season to begin planning for an earlier 2008 date," association director Douglas Hill told the House committee.

Exactly how late is unclear. Rendell opined last week that action could be taken as late as early October, although an official from the State Department told the House committee that June 30 is the "drop-dead" date.

The Pennsylvania School Boards Association warned that such a change would force boards to put their preliminary 2008-09 budgets on display by October — when it may be too early to obtain reliable estimates of certain costs, such as health insurance coverage, and other vital information.

Barring legislative action to accelerate the primary, Pennsylvania will hold its primary on April 22. More than one observer has speculated that, given the unprecedented primary lineup and the unpredictable consequences, the Keystone State's late event may surprise everybody and wind up settling a deadlocked nomination.

"Strange things happen in nominating seasons," said Sabato.

More in Pennsylvania News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS