Report finds many school districts should be merged
HARRISBURG — Certain school districts might reap considerable savings by consolidating with neighboring districts, but practical and political barriers make the process difficult, according to a legislative study released Wednesday.
The most likely place to find savings would be among relatively higher-spending smaller districts that might combine with lower-spending larger districts that have enrollments below 3,000 students, the study found.
The Legislative Budget and Finance Committee report, prepared by Standard & Poor's ratings service, identified 34 potential consolidations that could save a combined $81 million a year in operating costs and potentially provide better academic and extracurricular choices for students.
But consolidation efforts may face opposition because of cultural and economic differences between the districts, the prospect of higher taxes in one of the merging districts, longer bus trips for some students and resistance to closing neighborhood schools.
Even rivalries among sports teams could make it harder to get local support for consolidation, the study said.
"A number of individuals who were interviewed indicated that consolidation would not be likely to occur in their communities unless it was mandated by the state," the report said.
The study found no connection between the size of a district and how well its students score on state reading and math proficiency tests. It warned that performance benchmarks in the federal No Child Left Behind Act could prevent districts with relatively high scores from combining with a lower-scoring district.
The study found the annual per-pupil operating cost is $9,700 in districts of less than 500 students, hits a low of $8,100 for districts with between 2,500 and 3,000 students, and rises again for the larger districts.
Scott Shewell, a spokesman for the Pennsylvania School Boards Association, said there is no evidence that making districts larger improves student achievement.
The association believes consolidation decisions are best left to local officials.
"In a state as diverse as Pennsylvania, if you start forcing school consolidation from the state level, it's like trying to place a square peg in a round hole," Shewell said.
There are 501 public-school districts in Pennsylvania, down from more than 2,000 a half-century ago.
