Site last updated: Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Record law is mulled

Pa. lawmakers wary of 'flip'

HARRISBURG — The debate in the Pennsylvania Legislature over potential changes to the state's primary open-records law has focused lately on unintended consequences and worst-case scenarios.

That's not particularly good news for anyone expecting significant widening of the Right-to-Know Law.

Not that the prospect for change has died. The state Senate will conduct a hearing today about an open-records bill that has attracted 30 co-sponsors, and the House Speaker's Legislature Reform Commission plans to vote next week on which Right-to-Know Law changes it will recommend.

But it's far from clear that whatever eventually passes — if anything — will accomplish what open-records advocates call the "flip of presumption." The Senate bill doesn't do it and the reform commission might not be able to muster enough votes to endorse the idea either.

Right now, under the 1957 law that many consider among the nation's weakest, only two limited categories of records are necessarily open — minutes, orders and decisions, or accounts, vouchers and contracts — and even those have been pared by legislation and court rulings over the past half-century.

What most states do, and what is proposed in two pending bills and by Gov. Ed Rendell, is to flip that around by presuming everything is open to the public, then carve out a list of exceptions — for private medical records, police investigative materials or Social Security numbers, for example.

The reform commission has spent considerable time recently chewing over just how that might work, and whether a more open government is worth the price of potential invasions of privacy or the sort of disclosure that could compromise a criminal investigation.

The reaction, for some, has been to slow things down.

"If we think we're going to come up with the bill in the next weeks or months that's going to solve everything, I think we're naive," said Rep. Kerry Benninghoff, R-Centre, a reform commission member who hasn't decided how he will vote on flipping the presumption. "I also believe it would be better to be a little more cautious and expand as times goes on."

If the commission votes to flip the presumption, it will then consider whether to recommend that the House committee that will take up the issue from there — probably the State Government Committee — should use as its starting point a long list of exceptions culled from various sources.

Advocates are worried about how much will make it onto that list.

"At the end of the day, if we get the presumption, and then the list of exceptions is so all-inclusive that for all intents and purposes the presumption is meaningless, that wouldn't be a very good result," said James Blaine, a former Chester County newspaper publisher who is editing www.passopenrecords.org, a blog sponsored by the Pennsylvania Newspaper Association.

More in Pennsylvania News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS