Site last updated: Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Pa. Supreme Court protects superintendents from firing

HARRISBURG — Pennsylvania school boards do not have unfettered authority to fire their superintendents, the state Supreme Court said in a decision released Friday.

A state law requires a hearing and finding of "neglect of duty, incompetency, intemperance or immorality" before a superintendent is fired. The 5-2 ruling said that law does not conflict with a state constitutional provision that gives appointing bodies the ability to remove someone at their pleasure.

The case involved Anthony E. Burger, who was fired in January 2001 as head of the McGuffey School District in Washington County over allegations he sexually harassed a female subordinate. The high court sent the case back to a county judge to consider Burger's appeal of his dismissal.

"That the power of removal is not unlimited is a matter of common sense, since none could seriously dispute that an officer cannot be removed for an unconstitutional reason, such as a decision premised upon the race or gender of the officer," wrote Justice Ronald Castille for the majority.

He wrote that the reasons why the General Assembly might want to give special protection to untenured superintendents "are readily apparent, given the potential for conflict between superintendents and their school boards."

More in Pennsylvania News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS