Budget process streamlined
HARRISBURG — Rank-and-file state representatives agreed Tuesday to withdraw scores of budget amendments, forgoing the usual drawn-out debate over their pet projects and drawing early lines in the battle over next year's state spending.
House Appropriations Committee Chairman Dwight Evans, D-Philadelphia, said he persuaded members of his own caucus to withdraw their amendments Monday and Republicans agreed to the deal Tuesday.
Evans said the agreement would "move this process along" toward serious budget negotiations with the Senate and governor in June. The new budget year starts July 1.
"You know what usually happens: You go through the amendments, you've drawn this out for two or three days, and then what happens to your amendments?" Evans told the chamber.
The withdrawal of the amendments left two options for the House to consider: Gov. Ed Rendell's $27.3 billion budget or a scaled-down Republican plan based largely on maintaining the current year's spending plan and limiting the budget growth to less than 2 percent.
Democrats defeated the $26.8 billion GOP proposal 102-96, with only Speaker Dennis O'Brien, R-Philadelphia, crossing party lines. A vote on Rendell's budget was scheduled for Wednesday.
Rep. Mario Civera, R-Delaware, the ranking Republican on the Appropriations Committee, sponsored the alternative budget. It would have restored many of the items facing Rendell's ax for which members had proposed amendments.
"We know we have to control spending, and we can do it without gutting many of the programs," said House Minority Leader Sam Smith, R-Jefferson.
Smith said that if O'Brien's pattern of voting with Democrats continues, he may find Republican caucus meetings less than welcoming.
"I'd say that's wearing it pretty thin," Smith said.
The surprise approach on the budget amendments short-circuited an annual Harrisburg ritual in which state lawmakers hack away at the governor's proposal, looking for program cuts to free up cash for their own priorities.
Evans predicted Rendell's budget will be approved and sent to the Senate.
"I have 102 votes — that bill will pass," he said.
That would leave advocates for this year's crop of House budget amendments having to pin their hopes on a House-Senate conference committee.
In prior years, representatives have used the amendment process — which cynics have termed the "fake budget" — to fight for a piece of the budget pie and to show constituents and interest groups they are working on their behalf.
At stake are hundreds of millions in spending on everything from education and health care to such smaller-scale needs as county fairs and scrap-tire removal.
Amendments addressed proposals to fund school security, senior centers, agricultural exports, drivers' education, food safety and inspection. In the health care realm alone, they included initiatives regarding epilepsy, diabetes, lupus, autism, cancer, sickle-cell anemia, Tourette's syndrome and Lou Gehrig's disease.
Evans said he made no specific promises to return any of them to the final budget.
"I don't see the legislators walking away from those and just abandoning all those programs," Smith said.
Rep. Brian Ellis, R-11th, meanwhile, criticized the House-passed budget plan, arguing that state government must live within its means.
"I voted against this budget because I believe it is not fiscally responsible," Ellis said.
"Since Ed Rendell has been governor, the citizens of Pennsylvania have been paying for his increased spending and higher taxes to fund his initiatives and we, in the Legislature, must say no to his calls for spending above the rate of inflation."
Eagle staff writer Jim Smith contributed to this report.
