Site last updated: Saturday, November 21, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

State voters reject tax shift

Gov. blames confusion

HARRISBURG, Pa. — Pennsylvania voters said "no deal" to lower property taxes in return for higher local income taxes.

In 142 school districts reporting results of their tax-shift referendums early this morning, voters in only three appeared to accept the trade-off, according to returns posted early today on a Department of State Web site. The 142 represent more than 25 percent of the state's school districts.

The proposed tax shift was touted by the Rendell administration as a chance for homeowners to increase the size of the property-tax cuts they will receive once the state distributes slot-machine gambling revenue to school districts.

But voters weren't interested.

Chuck Ardo, spokesman for Gov. Ed Rendell, said opposition likely reflected voter confusion.

"The governor believes that voters ought to have local control over the mix of taxes that support their schools," Ardo said. "The dollar-for-dollar exchange (under the tax shifts) was straightforward. Unfortunately, the interpretation, by the time it got to the voters, seemed to be much more complicated."

Some variation of the question was asked in all but three of the state's 501 school districts under a 2006 law that promises to deliver as much as $1 billion a year in slots revenue for tax cuts financed by slot-machine gambling.

The ballot questions called for shifting at least 25 percent of the local school-tax burden — but not more than 50 percent — to a higher earned income tax, which most school districts already levy on wages and other compensation, or to a new local personal income tax. The personal income tax would apply to both wages and unearned income such as interest and dividends. Pensions and Social Security benefits are not taxed.

If approved, the tax shifts take effect July 1.

Senior citizens on fixed incomes and low-income homeowners would likely receive the greatest benefit from the tax shift because their property-tax reductions would far exceed the local income tax increase. By contrast, renters have the most to lose because they would pay higher income taxes and would not be eligible for any tax relief.

Taxpayer groups around the state campaigned against the tax shifts, saying they would not provide adequate tax cuts to all Pennsylvanians.

"I was out today at a number of polling places, and there were a few (voters) who were confused and didn't understand" the ballot question, said David Baldinger, a spokesman for the Pennsylvania Coalition of Taxpayer Associations, which comprises 23 local, regional and statewide taxpayer groups. "Those who were aware of it were resoundingly against it."

The questions were not asked in Philadelphia, Pittsburgh and Scranton, where wage taxes are already comparatively high.

More in Pennsylvania News

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS