PSU's pay secrets argued in court
HARRISBURG — The state's highest court heard arguments Monday on whether secret salaries of Penn State employees, including football coach Joe Paterno, should be released to the public.
Penn State will not disclose the salaries of its administrators and employees, and has tried to block an attempt by a reporter for the Patriot-News of Harrisburg to find out the salary of Paterno and three top administrators.
The school gets about 10 percent of its more than $3 billion budget from the state, but is a separate entity. The reporter, Jan Murphy, sought the salary information from the State Employees Retirement System, to which Paterno and the administrators belong.
The Supreme Court's chief justice, Ralph Cappy, repeatedly pressed Murphy's lawyer to explain how the salary information collected by the retirement system should be considered a public record under the state's Right-to-Know Law.
Both Staudenmaier and retirement system lawyer Brian McDonough contended that the salary records meet two of the definitions, because they are part of a government account and are a contract pertaining to each enrolled individual.
"It is most clearly a public record," Staudenmaier said.
Penn State and the state's three other "state-related" universities — Temple, Pittsburgh and Lincoln — are exempt from the Right-to-Know Law, which generally requires state agencies to promptly release when asked records of any account, voucher or contract, and any minute, order or decision.
Justice Thomas Saylor pointed out that simply enrolling in the retirement system — an option available to Penn State employees — defines workers as state employees, whose salaries are typically disclosed publicly.
Cappy questioned Penn State lawyer John Snyder about whether retirement system enrollees should have a reduced expectation of privacy.
Paterno and the three administrators joined the retirement system, called SERS, before it decided to make salaries public, and they should enjoy a cloak of privacy, Snyder said.
