Site last updated: Monday, November 16, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Doe theft a true puzzler

"Hand over the dough!"

That you expect to hear from when a thief holds you at gunpoint.

"Hand over the doe!"

That, however, you don't expect to hear when a thief holds you at gunpoint.

But that's just what a poor hunter from Meadville heard on Monday when three armed men came up to his little neck of the woods — literally — stuck their rifles in his face, and demanded his doe.

Not his dough, his doe.

Yes, apparently sticking up a human is much easier than blasting a doe yourself to these three fine wannabe "hunters."

Why shoot it when you can just steal one from someone else?

What's next? Thieves holding a lure to the jugular of a fisherman to steal his trout?

Those lures can be sharp, after all.

I don't know which is worse: The actual act, or the fact they did it to steal a doe.

A doe. A deer. A female deer.

Not a buck.

If there was a deer worth committing armed robbery and assault with a deadly weapon for, that would be it.

The more points the better. Eight, 12, 18, whatever. Steal that one.

Not a doe, for crying out loud!

It's like robbing a jewelry store and passing up the diamonds for a nice haul of cubic zirconium.

Of course, we are talking about people who stole a deer from a hunter, with rifles presumably bought to hunt deer, not people, to begin with, so they are not the sharpest crayons in the box.

Here are some possible motivations for their crime:

• The trio, frustrated that they couldn't bag a deer on their own, concocted a plan to thrill and delight their friends by roaming the woods looking for some dude with a deer to "liberate."

Now, they can brag about the doe they shot and killed. How they chased it over hill and dale, over the river and through the woods, zeroed in on it and shot it.

Wink. Wink. Nudge. Nudge.

• They are friends of the doe's family, their desire to give it a proper burial so great, they took the law into their own hands.

Sounds like a Lifetime movie.

• They had an extreme craving for venison. I've never had venison myself, but I have been told it tastes nothing like chicken.

• The 40 or so deer carcasses strewn up and down Route 422 weren't good enough.

• They thought, "Wouldn't it be funny to rob a hunter?"

• They are like Robin Hood: stealing deer from the rich to give to the poor.

Police have no suspects.

I'm sure there isn't a criminal profile out there for a "deer thief."

Here's a hint: They are wearing camouflage and orange hats.

And want your dough, er, doe.

More in Sports

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS