Michigan deserves another chance
There's a argument floating out there that a second-place team in a conference should not have the right to play for a national championship in college football.
I'm here to ask: "Why not?"
No. 1-ranked Ohio State's thrilling 42-39 victory over Big Ten Conference rival Michigan Saturday was among the top games of the season.
The Wolverines entered undefeated and ranked No. 2 behind the unbeaten Buckeyes. There are a handful of one-loss teams clamoring for their chance at the Buckeyes, but shouldn't Michigan have another crack at them?
If you are going to have a poll, Michigan is Michigan. Ohio State is Ohio State. Southern Cal is Southern Cal. A team is still a team. You can't lump a team in a conference, then penalize that team for losing to someone else in the conference.
If only conference champions could compete for the national championship, then make that a criteria for the Bowl Championship Series. Oddly, it's a team-by-team sport when it comes to the BCS poll, but a conference sport when it comes to the actual Bowl Championship Series itself.
Michigan (11-1) and Ohio State (12-0) have separated themselves from the rest of the pack. The thought going into last week's game was that if the loser kept it close, especially Michigan since it was the road team, and it came down to the last possession, that team would deserve another shot.
And Michigan should.
Michigan now finds itself grouped with top 10-ranked teams with one loss like USC (9-1), Florida (10-1), Arkansas (10-1), Notre Dame (10-1), West Virginia (9-1), Louisville (9-1) and Wisconsin (11-1).
The Wolverines, however, should not suffer since their game came so late in the season. Why does a tough loss early in the year cost less than one later? A loss earlier in the year can be overcome like Florida's (against Auburn) and Notre Dame's (a 47-21 blowout loss at home against Michigan), but one late can kill you and cost the school millions of dollars in bowl money.
If that's the case — and sadly it is — I'd try like crazy not to schedule any tough games late in the season. I'd play it as early as I could and try and run the table and avoid any slips (see Rutgers).
Teams in the Southeastern Conference have a championship final of their own, all but killing the loser's shot at a national championship.
The only teams that should have a chance to play Ohio State Jan. 8 should be Michigan, USC, Florida and Notre Dame. USC still has games against Notre Dame and UCLA, wins that could propel them into the No. 2 spot since OSU and Michigan are done with their regular seasons.
Notre Dame needs that win over USC to have any shot.
Florida needs the SEC championship game win against Arkansas, but that still wouldn't be enough. It should come down to USCor Michigan.
It should be Michigan and OSU for the title game. Can they top last week, which drew the best ratings in the past 13 years?
It certainly would be fun to find out. And to watch. And isn't that what matters most?
