Site last updated: Thursday, November 19, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

There's no quit in Cathell

When is it OKto quit? In Garry Cathell's mind, it's never.

If ever the Butler High School football coach was going to stop trying to win a game, it would have been in the second half of last week's season finale against Erie Cathedral Prep.

The game was an added 10th regular season contest for a Golden Tornado team officially eliminated from playoff contention the week before. The score reached 35-0 in Cathedral Prep's favor with more than nine minutes left in the third quarter.

The mercy clock began running and Cathedral Prep's reserves began running onto the field to finish out the night.

Game over, right?

Not according to Cathell.

Butler's first unit remained in the game, recovered two onside kicks, scored three touchdowns and infuriated Cathedral Prep coach Don Holl.

Holl referred to the Golden Tornado's actions as "an insult to football."

Holl described the game as being "over" when the score reached 35-0.

If the game was over, the scoreboard would have been turned off, the players would have hit the showers and everybody would have gone home.

Instead, Butler kept playing. And because it did, Cathedral Prep chose to throw a long pass to get a first down inside Butler's 5-yard line with a minute to play, call timeout so it could score another touchdown, then try an onside kick with seconds left to try to score again.

Moves like that could be described as "an insult to football."

Yet Cathell had no problem with those plays. If a team wants to score more points, it was fine by him.

That is the object of the game, after all.

At some point, sportsmanship left this game. What's hard to figure out is when that happened.

Cathedral Prep had a playoff game to get ready for. Ahead 35-0, it's easy to understand Holl not wanting to get any of his starters injured.

Butler had a lot of seniors playing their final game, and they were playing it on their home field. I can understand Cathell not wanting to pull the plug on their efforts halfway through the game.

Cathell never gave up trying to win. If Butler does change coaches during this off-season, failure to win in league play will have cost him his job.

During Cathell's five years at Butler, the Tornado were 10-9 in nonconference games, 7-24 in conference games. Take away the Seneca Valley games and Butler is 3-23 in league play over the past five years.

The number of students playing football is up, the booster organization is merged and solid, and Butler's Hometown Heroes program is recognizing deserving players, coaches and supporters from years gone by.

All of those things have happened under Cathell's watch.

But the wins haven't come, so the coach might go.

If he does, he never quit trying to win — and his team never quit on him.

Even if the other team didn't like it.

More in Sports

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS