Winning won't always save managers
Managers are hired to be fired.
Everybody knows that statement is true, and a few managers were sent packing immediately following the end of the 2006 Major League Baseball regular season.
But two of these dismissals are borderline ridiculous — and show that winning isn't everything.
Joe Girardi kept the Florida Marlins in the National League wild-card race until late September despite taking the reins of a team that had 22 rookies on its 40-man roster.
We'd take that in Pittsburgh, wouldn't we?
Not far removed from his own playing days, Girardi guided the Marlins to a 78-84 final record. Hanley Ramirez is a Rookie of the Year candidate, as is Rule 5 player Dan Uggla.
Miguel Cabrera nearly won the batting title and Josh Willingham, a rookie catcher developed by Girardi, who was a catcher himself, developed into an impressive player.
Alas, Girardi had a falling out with ownership, was nearly fired during the season and was fired immediately after the season.
Even worse is the case of Ken Macha, a former Pittsburgh Pirates player who guided the low-budget Oakland A's to a second division title in four years.
In 2005, the A's led the American League West by a game going into September, eventually missing the playoffs with a still-solid 88-74 record.
This year, the A's won 93 games, won the West and dispatched Minnesota in three straight games in the first round of the playoffs.
We'd take that in Pittsburgh, wouldn't we?
Not in Oakland. Swept by Detroit in the American League Championship Series, the A's decided to sweep Macha out of the managerial chair.
What gives?
This is a franchise that's lost Jason Giambi, Miguel Tejada, Jason Isringhausen, Mark Mulder and Tim Hudson to free agency in recent years. It is a franchise that almost certainly will lose ace pitcher Barry Zito to free agency this year.
Oakland general manager Billy Beane said he dismissed Macha because he saw a "disconnection" between the manager and the rest of the organization. He didn't feel Macha's player development was up to snuff.
Huh?
Dan Haren, Esteban Loaiza, Huston Street, Eric Chavez, Bobby Crosby, Mark Ellis, Nick Swisher — they flourished under Macha's leadership.
The organization brought in malcontents like Jason Kendall, Frank Thomas and Milton Bradley — and Macha made it work.
True, managers are hired to be fired. But whatever happened to, if it ain't broke, don't fix it?
Maybe the Marlins and A's will continue to go in positive directions next year, but why take the gamble? Girardi and Macha both have years left on their contracts and both were fired by franchises that can ill-afford unnecessary expenses.
Girardi and Macha likely will land on their feet and manage somewhere else if they want to.
Until then, this is yet another head-scratcher in the befuddling world of professional sports.
