Mental stumbling blocks hurt some teams
High school football in Western Pennsylvania could be described as the haves and have-nots.
It should be described as the do's and the do-not's.
Almost every year at this time the usual suspects are sitting at or near the top of the WPIALstandings in their respective classifications.
In Class AAAA, Upper St. Clair began play this weekend at 6-0. Central Catholic was 5-1, as was Woodland Hills and McKeesport, Penn Hills was 4-1, North Hills and North Allegheny 4-2.
In AAA, Thomas Jefferson, Pine-Richland and Blackhawk were 6-0, Franklin Regional and Hopewell 5-1.
In AA, there's Greensburg Central Catholic and Aliquippa undefeated, Seton-LaSalle and Center sitting at 5-1. Class A has Rochester, Beth-Center and Clairton all unbeaten.
Ho-hum, ho-hum, ho-hum.
Yes, occasionally, somebody will break through. Shaler is off to a 5-1 start, as are Kittanning and Highlands. Those programs have won before, but not all the time.
For the most part, the same teams win year in and year out.
The question is why.
Why did Butler, with an experienced, senior-laden team, take a 2-4 record to North Hills, an inexperienced 4-2 team that considers its record a "down" year?
Every community has players who can throw a football, catch one, kick one, block and tackle. Yet some communities always seem to lose and other communities always seem to win.
It's easy to blame it on coaching. Notions these days are to dump Garry Cathell at Butler, Ron Butschle at Seneca Valley, Mike King at Knoch — these guys just aren't getting it done, right?
Reality shows that those three programs haven't put consistently winning teams on the field now for quite some time, pre-dating all three.
Butler began this season with a 26-0 shutout at Kiski Area, a team that has won three of five games since while averaging 25 points per game.
Seneca Valley won three of its first four games.
The Golden Tornado and Raiders began this weekend 0-2 in conference play. Seneca Valley hasn't won a conference game in three years. Other than beating Seneca Valley, neither has Butler.
Confidence — truly believing you will win and expecting to win as opposed to trying to win and hoping to win — is everything in high school football.
Every coaching staff knows the X's and O's. This game isn't that fancy. No one's invented anything new in football in years.
Executing on the field comes from confidence. Players won't do the former without the latter.
Programs can turn around. Yough was a perennial loser for years. This year, it's 5-1 and outscoring opponents by a 38-12 margin per game.
Somewhere along the line, those kids realized they can play this game.
That's a mental hurdle that is tough to overcome.
