Site last updated: Friday, November 20, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Teams coddle athletes too much

The Pittsburgh Penguins kept goaltender Marc-Andre Fleury on their roster despite a subpar preseason performance because they didn't want to damage his psyche by sending him down to Wilkes-Barre.

The Pittsburgh Pirates took forever before sending Oliver Perez to Class AAAIndianapolis because they didn't want to ruin his confidence.

Those same Pirates allowed center fielder Chris Duffy two months to ponder whether he wanted to accept his demotion to Indianapolis after hitting below .200 for the Bucs in April and May.

Is there some sort of trend here?

I'm not sure how or when it got started, but we sure do seem a lot more concerned about an athlete's psyche than we used to be.

Granted, once Duffy did finally report to Indianapolis, he straightened out his game and wound up helping the Pirates down the stretch.

Of course, had he reported right away, he might have helped the Pirates for 30 or 40 more games this season.

There's been talk that if the Penguins send Fleury down now, they could lose him for good mentally. What in the world does that mean?

If a goaltender is filled with that kind of self-doubt, he's not going to succeed long-term in the NHL anyway.

The Pirates allowed Perez to stink out the joint time and time again at the big league level — like that helped his confidence — and even sent him to the bullpen before finally sending him to the minor leagues and eventually out of the organization.

These people are adults. We don't need to coddle them. We don't need to worry about hurting their feelings or damaging them for life.

If they're not good enough to wear the uniform right now, they're not good enough.

If I'm deemed not good enough to do my job anymore, believe me, the higher-ups will tell me and I won't have my job to do anymore.

Nobody will be concerned about hurting my feelings. That's true with just about every job out there.

Unless you're an athlete. For some reason, you will be coddled and treated like a fragile child forever.

If only I had a dime for every time I picked up the phone and heard from a parent about how little Bobby was "devastated" because his name wasn't in a story or his face wasn't in a picture.

If a kid isn't seeing significant playing time, it's always because the coach doesn't like him or has no eye for talent.

It can't be that the kid isn't good enough. And if things aren't going the way you want, hey, just quit the team. That's acceptable these days.

So Manny can keep on being Manny, Terrell Owens can keep finding a team to play for, Barry Bonds can keep treating everybody like dirt.

The sports world continues to be a safe haven for these people.

The first time Marc-Andre Fleury lets in a soft goal at Mellon Arena, don't boo him too loudly, now.

Wouldn't want to damage his psyche.

After all, who do you think he is — Cliff Stoudt?

More in Sports

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS