Pirates' trades are puzzling
The trade winds have blown through Pittsburgh once again, so it's time to assess the damage.
The Pirates' deals before the July 31 trade deadline weren't all that bad, though a couple of things are a bit puzzling.
Why give up on Oliver Perez so soon? Why say goodbye to Sean Casey so quickly?And what is this never-ending fascination with Xavier Nady?
It's also surprising that Joe Randa, who is hitting, and Jeromy Burnitz, who isn't, are still here.
Roberto Hernandez was having a nice year out of the bullpen as a setup man, but he is 40 years old and won't be around if the Pirates ever start winning again.
He can help the New York Mets in the playoffs, which is why they got him. They've already tucked the NLEast title in their back pocket.
Craig Wilson was a power bat from the right side but also is a man without a position as a National League player, and he strikes out too much.
If he's used as a platoon designated hitter against left-handed pitching for the New York Yankees, he'll help them down the stretch. He's a free agent at the end of the year and was out of here anyway.
Kip Wells also is a free agent at the end of the year and is not worth the $4.15 million he makes a year. He had a couple of nice starts recently, enabling the Pirates to deal him to Texas.
Wells is a good guy and is worth wishing well, but his price tag, his injury problems and other struggles didn't make him worth the risk in Pittsburgh.
All of that makes sense.
But ...
Not trying to re-sign Casey may be a mistake. He was one of only two players in the Pirates lineup — Freddy Sanchez is the other — who makes consistent contact at the plate.
Besides, Casey was shown the door without any sure-fire replacement at first base in place. The Pirates might try to make Nady a first baseman, but he's an outfielder.
Speaking of the outfield, recalling Chris Duffy to play center and moving Jose Bautista to right are OKmoves. Play the young guys and see what they can do. But why add Nady, who isn't needed here, at the expense of losing Perez?
The Pirates claim they didn't give up on Perez, that they traded him because of their heavy concentration of left-handed starting pitchers. But if they believe there's any hope he could return to his 239-strikeout form of 2004, there's no way they trade him.
Perez doesn't turn 25 until Aug. 15. He came up in the San Diego Padres' system and the Padres tried to reacquire him from the Mets last week.
The Padres know Perez's potential, so they tried to get him back.
The good news is the Pirates did not deal Mike Gonzalez, who has converted all 19 of his save opportunities, or shortstop Jack Wilson, who is hitting .370 since the all-star break.
Slowly, the Pirates have put some of the pieces in place. They have freed up some money to spend for 2007.
Here's hoping they spend it more wisely than they did this year.
Just think: if the Pirates were even five games below .500, they'd be in the wild-card race.
