Site last updated: Sunday, November 22, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

One last defense of the Steelers

Just when does the statute of limitations run out when it comes to defending a Super Bowl championship?

The Pittsburgh Steelers defeated the Seattle Seahawks 21-10 in Super Bowl XL 10 days ago, yet the Steelers have to defend the fact they won the game, not the officials.

Not even the NHL's gambling ring has been able to knock the fallout off the pages. So, let's do this one final time:

The touchdown by Seattle's Darrell Jackson that was disallowed due to a pushoff.

The thinking was there was no contact or minimal contact, so no flag should have been thrown, or Steelers' defensive back Chris Hope egged the official to throw the flag.

Bottom line: Jackson did push off in the end zone in front of the official. A non-call is for a 10-yard gain near midfield, not on the NFL's biggest stage.

Ben Roethlisberger's goal-line touchdown. It appeared the edge of the ball came close to the front of the goal line with Roethlisberger in flight. By the time he landed he had been knocked back.

Bottom line: The replay showed nothing different and it did appear that the ball crossed the line, albeit briefly.

The holding call on Seattle lineman Sean Locklear that negated an 18-yard pass play that could have given Seattle a first-and-goal at the 1-yard line, trailing 14-10.

Also, the 15-yard penalty added onto Ike Taylor's return of a Matt Hasslebeck's interception.

Bottom line: These are two calls you could say hurt the Seahawks. On the hold, a chance to take the lead early in the fourth quarter that would have completely swung the momentum in the team's favor was gone. Ouch.

The illegal block by Hasselbeck on the return also was a poor call, although there's nothing that says the Steelers wouldn't have scored anyway, as evidenced by Antwaan Randle El's 43-yard scoring pass to Hines Ward moments later.

But there were two plays that have drawn little or no attention that could have affected the Steelers.

With the Steelers leading 14-3 and looking for more, Roethlisberger's pass was intercepted by Kelly Herndon inside the 5-yard line and returned to the Steelers' 24-yard line.

Roethlisberger dropped back to try and make a tackle, but he was clearly pushed in the back with two hands.

Bottom line: A 10-yard penalty at the spot of the infraction would have moved the ball back to about the Pittsburgh 45-yard line.

Jerramy Stevens was hit after a pass reception that was ruled incomplete. Stevens caught the pass, had two feet down, turned, then was hit and fumbled. The officials blew the whistle to stop the play.

Bottom line: A challenge, which was not applicable here due to the whistle, would have given Pittsburgh the ball, as Joey Porter was nearby.

Seattle complained quite a bit, especially coach Mike Holmgren, the day after the game, but I didn't see anybody touch Willie Parker on his 75-yard scoring run or Ward on his touchdown catch. I also saw Jackson catch zero passes after the first quarter, not to mention Stevens' four dropped passes.

The difference in this game was adversity. In the earlier playoff game against Indianapolis, Troy Polamalu's interception appeared to seal a Pittsburgh win. Before the call was overturned, coach Bill Cowher implored his players not to let the outcome of the decision affect them.

They didn't and that helped propel them to the eventual title. Seattle did, and that's what cost them the championship.

More in Sports

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS