Site last updated: Sunday, November 22, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Optimism comes cheap for Pirates

OK. Football season is now officially over.

The Steelers are Super Bowl champions, so road crews can now salt the streets and stores can quit treating the Black and Gold like Santa Claus.

We can stop playing "Here we go" and that eerie "Polamalu" song set to the Muppets "Phenomena."

We can fold up our Chris Gardocki jerseys and put them away for another six months and get on with our lives.

No Pro Bowl parties. No countdown to the NFL All-Star game.

It will be baseball season soon, so all the fans in Pittsburgh can come crashing down to Earth again.

Ah, yes, the Pirates. When last we heard of them before the sound of the grinding wheels of the Steelers' bandwagon drowned out all other noise, they were selling optimism on their winter caravan.

They boasted of offseason moves that brought Sean Casey and Jeromy "I'll play for any team for at least one season" Burnitz to the 'Burgh.

They lauded a starting rotation of young left-handers and of a coaching staff committed to bringing respectability to PNC Park.

Yes. We have heard all of this before.

Wasn't Derek Bell supposed to be a great off-season move? How about Chris Stynes? Wasn't he supposed to be an upgrade at third base?

Those moves certainly worked out well. Bell went into Operation Shutdown long after his bat went into Operation Whiff. Stynes hit one home run, fielded horribly and didn't last long enough for anyone in Pittsburgh to start hating him.

But it is February and every team in the major leagues is happy in February.

It's just those pesky summer months that ruin everything.

The Pirates are selling optimism. But optimism won't hit 20 home runs or drive in 100. Optimism won't get anyone out. Optimism won't field its position at a major league level.

Only players — good players — do that, and during the last 13 seasons, Pittsburgh hasn't had enough of them on the baseball diamond.

But, who knows? Maybe this will be the year that the Pirates catch lightning in a bottle.

Maybe Casey will bat .325 and drive in 90 to 100 runs. Maybe Joe Randa will play like, well, Joe Randa and give the Bucs a consistent, if unspectacular, bat.

Maybe Kip Wells will discover that he has pretty good stuff and not try to be David Wells every time he goes out to the mound and nibble at the corners as well as the buffet table.

Maybe Burnitz will hit 40 home runs and strike out only 120 times instead of 150.

And maybe Oliver Perez will find the form that made him a rookie of the year candidate and give Pittsburgh a bona fide ace.

That's a lot of maybes.

Some history is on the Bucs side.

The last time the Steelers won the Super Bowl, the Pirates also won the World Series.

So, crazier things have happened.

But I wouldn't buy those World Series tickets yet. They cost a lot more than optimism these days.

More in Sports

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS