When is it OK to aim low?
When it comes to sports — or anything, for that matter — is it ever OK to give less than your best?
Is it ever OK to even want to lose?
A story in a recent edition of the Eagle concerning bowler Mike Hilliard of South Butler brought such a question to the minds of a few readers.
Hilliard is one of the top bowlers in the area and has rolled seven 300-games in his lifetime. He also has rolled a 299 or two in his day.
Not too long ago, Hilliard started a game with 11 consecutive strikes. He didn't want another perfect game. He wanted a 298 — a score he's never bowled — and the ring that goes with it.
Trying to get a eight pins on his 12th shot, he wound up getting a six and a 296 game.
Hilliard didn't harm his team's chances of winning that night by going for a 298. Yet some people are bothered that he didn't try for a strike and a perfect game.
The question: Is it OK to do what he did, to sacrifice doing his best, in order to achieve another goal?
NFL teams have been accused of losing on purpose for alternative gains. Go back to 1969, when the 1-6 Steelers lost to the 0-7 Chicago Bears 38-7.
That was the Bears' only win that season. The Steelers also finished 1-13, but by virtue of their loss to Chicago, got the first pick in the 1970 NFL Draft and selected Terry Bradshaw.
How different would Steelers history be if they hadn't gotten that pick.
Did the Steelers lose to the Bears on purpose? Who knows, but the Bears weren't 31 points better than them that year.
Then there's the 1982-83 Penguins. They and the New Jersey Devils were the NHL's two worst teams that season. Everybody in the hockey world knew Mario Lemieux would be the league's No. 1 draft choice during the off-season.
The Penguins played a late-season game in New Jersey, called up a rookie goalie from the minor leagues, played him and lost — and wound up with Lemieux.
Coincidence? Maybe. But no one can dispute the fact the Penguins franchise benefited from losing that game.
There always will be circumstances in which a team might be better served in the long run by losing. Maybe the outcome of a team's game affects another team's playoff chances or its own playoff opponent.
Maybe a team wants to rest its players to avoid a late-season injury. The Indianapolis Colts might want to do that in their season finale with Arizona, sacrificing a perfect season for a healthy shot at the Super Bowl.
Arizona might not be crazy about Indy's generosity. The Cardinals might want to finish with a better draft pick for April.
No team or person is likely to come out and say it doesn't want to win. Teams have done less than their best on purpose, usually by not playing its best people.
Sandbagging does exist in bowling, where bowlers don't do their best in order to keep their averages at a certain point for benefit of the team or themselves.
Hilliard wanted a 298 and went for it.
Ironic as it seems, he might have gone for that strike and gotten the 298.
He'll never know.
And we'll never know whether teams really are trying their best, regardless of the situation.
