Site last updated: Monday, November 16, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Time for soul-searching in Harrisburg

The Pennsylvania Constitution requires all legislators and judges, every governor, all row officers and other public officials to take an oath of office:

“I do solemnly swear (or affirm) that I will support, obey and defend the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of this Commonwealth and that I will discharge the duties of my office with fidelity.” Article VI, Section 3.

The greatest part of the public angst over the pay raise is the apparent violation of the constitution, and not just with respect to the pay raise itself but with the increasing reliance on “stealth legislation” to preclude public discussion of important and far-reaching laws.

The pay raise conspicuously violated no fewer than three — possibly more — provisions of our constitution. It is hard to see how all those oath-takers are “discharging” the duties of their office with fidelity.

Nevertheless, in his first remarks about the pay raise in more than two months, House Speaker John Perzel declared that he will not allow a vote on repealing the pay raise unless there are 102 votes for it. This is no empty threat in a General Assembly where the outcome of votes on legislation — like the outcome of elections in the former Soviet Union — is always assured before the votes are cast and counted.

But lawmakers have the chance for redemption through the wild card known as the “discharge resolution.”

Both the House (Rule 53 — Discharge of Committees) and Senate (Rule 15 — Committees, paragraph 17) allow for rank-and-file members to insist that legislation be “discharged” from the committee to which it has been referred and brought to the floor for a vote.

The “discharge resolution” is one of the few ways in which rank-and-file members can wrest control from party leadership.

In the House, a discharge resolution requires the signatures of only 25 members. Given that currently there are nearly 40 members who are co-sponsoring the repeal legislation (House Bill 1945), there should be a discharge resolution in the House’s future.

However, discharge resolutions in the House are only valid after 15 “legislative days” — days in which the legislature is in session. Under the published calendar for the House, it will take 61 calendar days from Sept. 14 (the day I am writing this) — until

Nov. 15 — before 15 “legislative days” have elapsed, assuming that “leadership” does not cancel some legislative days in order to prolong the agony.

Even so, another rule — House Rule 77 — allows members to “suspend the rules” by a two-thirds vote, including the rule requiring a waiting period of 15 “legislative days.”

Senate Rule 26 is more rational, requiring only a majority of members to suspend the rules. Rules are routinely suspended in both chambers to force expeditious action on “leadership” priorities.

In the Senate, discharge resolutions can occur by unanimous consent at any time or by majority vote after just 10 legislative days. But the resolution must wait one “legislative day” before it can be placed on the calendar under the “Order of Business of Resolutions.”

Questions for legislators

For House members: Considering that the pay raise was introduced and enacted in a matter of hours, why should citizens have to wait as long as 61 days before the House votes on whether to repeal the pay raise?

Will you support setting a date certain, prior to Nov. 15, for a vote on repeal of the pay raise? When should that be? Should it be before the deadline — Oct. 11 — for voters to register for the November election?

Will you vote to suspend the rules in order to allow an immediate discharge resolution on House Bill 1945?

For Senate members: Will you vote to suspend the rules in order to give immediate consideration to HB 1945 when it is passed by the House?

Will you support a discharge resolution to bring any repeal legislation to the floor for a vote as soon as possible?

To all legislators: Will you allow “leadership” to stonewall a vote on repealing the pay raise? Or will you seek to replace members of “leadership” with legislators who believe in restoring integrity to the process of enacting laws in Pennsylvania?

What in the performance of the “leadership” that has controlled the legislature for decades warrants continued support by the rank and file? How has Pennsylvania’s position among the states improved or declined under these leaders on key indicators of economic, social and political well-being?

Will rank-and-file legislators support term limits for service in leadership positions in the House and Senate? If not, why not? If so, what should those limits be?

These are the constitutional provisions arguably violated by Act 44 of 2005 (the pay raise):

“No law shall be passed except by bill, and no bill shall be so altered or amended, on its passage through either House, as to change its original purpose.” Article III, Section 1. (The original purpose of the legislation had nothing to do with compensation for legislators or members of the judiciary.)

“No bill shall be passed containing more than one subject, which shall be clearly expressed in its title, except a general appropriations bill or a bill compiling or codifying the law or a part thereof.” Article III, Section 3. (The sole subject of the original legislation was compensation of certain officials in the executive branch.)

“Every bill shall be considered

on three different days in each

House. . . .” Article III, Section 4. (Not a single word of the original legislation was included in the final pay raise law, making it impossible for the bill to have been considered in either chamber, much less each chamber, for three different days.)

“The members of the General Assembly shall receive such salary and mileage for regular and special sessions as shall be set by law, and no other compensation whatever, whether for service upon committee or other-

wise. . . .” Article II, Section 8, Part 1. (The pay raise law provides additional compensation for officers of committees and for legislators “otherwise” in leadership positions. This provision of the constitution has never been litigated.)

“ . . . No member of either House shall during the term for which he may have been elected, receive any increase of salary, or mileage, under any law passed during such term.” Article II, Section 8, Part 2. (The pay raise law permits “unvouchered expenses” equivalent to the increase in salary until the end of the terms for which incumbent legislators have been elected.)

Timothy Potts is a former director of communications for the state House Democratic Caucus. He is a co-founder of Democracy Rising Pa.

More in Other Voices

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS