OTHER VOICES
The bankruptcies of Delta and Northwest mark the latest twists in the seemingly endless financial agony of America's mismanaged airline industry. Five large carriers are now flying broke.
The airline industry has been lurching near the brink of ruin for 20 years. If any other industry suffered the ailments of the airlines, the mess would have been cleaned up long ago. Inefficient companies either would have shrunk or died.
Instead, the airlines lost $33 billion between 2001 and 2004. Airlines carrying half America's passengers are financial zombies kept animated by the bankruptcy courts while they bleed more billions. This is made possible partly by the airlines' friends: Airline suppliers - such as General Electric - step in with financing so that busted airlines can keep buying. Small cities kick in subsidies to get airline service.
Creditors and bankruptcy judges accept rosy forecasts when letting bankrupt airlines off the hook. USAirways is on its second bankruptcy. TWA went broke three times before disappearing.
Then, there's Uncle Sam. The latest bankruptcies should teach him a lesson: Emergencies are a time for hard-headedness. The airline industry already was losing billions before Sept. 11, 2001. Congress then jumped in with $5 billion in grants and billions more in loan guarantees. In hindsight, that money was wasted. It postponed the reckoning. Airlines are going belly-up today despite passenger counts that are back to levels of boom year 2000.
Now, there is a movement in Congress to cut airline fuel taxes. In a bankruptcy, that simply means less money for Uncle Sam and more for the airline's creditors and perhaps its employees. The federal deficit was running at an annual $330 billion before Katrina added at least $62 billion more. Cutting taxes in the face of that is foolish. Besides, fuel taxes discourage the use of oil, and that's smart. .
The airlines are pressing for more time to bring their pension funds out of the red. Delta's pension alone is $10 billion short. That, too, is a bad idea. The federal Pension Benefit Guarantee Corporation, which insures pensions, already is running $27 billion short of what it needs to meet its obligations.
The government is considering giving all companies five to seven years to bring underfunded pensions up to snuff. The airlines want 25 years. During that time, they'd run up more pension obligations, making the ultimate bailout worse. No sentient being would bet a dime on the chances that any airline, other than a discounter, will survive five more years, much less 25. The savings and loan crisis of the 1980s taught us that it's better to deal with financial failures quickly, rather than let them fester.
Higher fuel costs pushed Delta and Northwest over the bankruptcy brink, but they were teetering anyway, and sky-high fuel costs may be a long-term reality. The latest casualties suffer from the same maladies that pushed USAirways and United and others into Chapter 11 well before Katrina.
Twenty-seven years after deregulation, the so-called "legacy" carriers still have not learned to compete. Well-run discounters such as Southwest and JetBlue underprice them and swipe their customers.
Government could help by erasing rules against foreign airlines investing in U.S. carriers. Big hub-and-spoke airlines should drastically downsize, turning small-city service over to commuter carriers. Labor must accept lower pay and benefits, because a lesser job is better than no job.
Airlines that can't cut it should liquidate. Consumers, who have benefited mightily from fare wars, might pay a little more. But as long as Southwest can sell a ticket from St. Louis to Chicago for $64, its competitors will have to match it.
