Site last updated: Tuesday, November 17, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Readers split over response to Katrina

With accusations flying and federal officials planning hearings, the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina raises more questions than answers with each passing day. When I wrote about the catastrophe a week ago, mostly out of concern for victims, I hardly expected nearly 500 readers to respond.

I do, however, stand by my position that the early federal reaction to the disaster was slow, inadequate and shameful. That said, here's a sample of reader views:

Dorothy Freier of Waupaca, Wis., wrote, "It is so easy for you or Prime Minister (Ariel) Sharon to say what should be done (to help) the people of the hurricane disaster. But saying and doing are not that simple a matter."

Orlando, Fla., resident Jack Wajda's answer to my question - Where is the cavalry? - was that "it no longer exists as a functioning agency. President George W. Bush has marginalized the capability of FEMA. What we observed last week is the result of his politicizing of a critical government agency."

From Yorba Linda, Calif., Robert Robison appeared fed up with the blame-mongering: "I am volunteering to go to the Gulf area and work as an assistant to the Red Cross. There is a time to blame, and there is a time to cowboy the hell up and get to the business at hand. Cowboy the hell up!"

Bob Kring of Longwood, Fla., begged to differ: 1. The president was out of touch with the devastation. 2. Where was Homeland Security? 3. Where were the heads of the Senate and House? 4. The National Guard was primarily in Iraq. 5. FEMA crawled up to the plate, and then only after news teams criticized its response. 6. What happened to all that "preparedness" after 9-11? "Are we ready as a nation to fight terrorism? No. What we have shown the world is that the United States is vulnerable and pathetically ill-prepared," Kring wrote.

Daniel Kormanik of Newtown, Conn., offered a former pilot's perspective. He allowed as how the media have minimized the sheer size of the affected region. To him, the kind of massive response required easily should have taken four days. Kormanik also mentioned that people have overloaded on media hype about storms, which can lead to complacency. "Next time, (the media) need to tell people up front that, yes, you will get help, but depending upon how vast and severe the damage is, it might be three to five days. That is why when (asked) to evacuate, you should follow the instructions, not refuse," he said.

Phil Edmunds of Boalsburg, Pa., wanted more details to substantiate claims of federal mismanagement and pointed his finger at local officials: "If you're still disposed to criticize elected officials or bureaucrats for their disaster preparation and response, consider New Orleans Mayor Ray Nagin. News reports indicate that Nagin failed to issue an evacuation order for the city until the day before Katrina came ashore. He failed to use more than 500 city, school and municipal transit buses to facilitate evacuation of city residents. He failed to vigorously enforce his evacuation order. A column on Nagin should write itself."

Finally, Del Cain of Orlando returned the focus to where it belongs during the long-term: better preparedness. Cain hoped that in a future column I might mention the use of trains: "If you have a Category 5 storm approaching a major U.S. city, and you have 100,000 poor people without cars, the only way to move (them) quickly and efficiently out of harm's way is by train. Rail also (allows you) to quickly move troops and their supplies. A healthy rail system is, to me, a national defense priority and a great asset for natural disasters."

More in Other Voices

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS