Other Voices
The selection of R. David Paulison to become the next director of the Federal Emergency Management Agency is an excellent way to begin restoring FEMA's reputation and ability to carry out its mission. Paulison is a former head of the Miami-Dade Fire Rescue Department and enjoys more than 30 years of experience in fire/rescue services. If ever a government agency needed rescuing, it's FEMA, and Paulison has the right credentials for this crucial job.
The resignation of Michael Brown as FEMA director came not a day too soon. As the hurricane season reaches its peak, Americans who live within reach of these devastating storms need to feel confident that disaster response is in capable hands. Brown's performance in the wake of Hurricane Katrina had made it amply clear that he was unqualified to hold this important position.
Paulison, on the other hand, fits the profile of a seasoned, professional manager in the realm of emergency response. In addition to his many years of service locally, he has served since late 2001 as head of the U.S. Fire Administration, a branch of FEMA. His numerous awards and commendations include being named Fire Chief of the Year by his colleagues in Florida in 1993. He is a certified paramedic whose emergency management experience includes Hurricane Andrew and the crash of ValuJet Flight 592.
Now it's up to President Bush and Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff to make sure that the new head of FEMA is surrounded by equally professional managers rather than the political cronies who moved in alongside Brown. In recent years, far too many positions at FEMA have been used as rewards for political allies. The position of chief of staff, for example, is held by Patrick J. Rhode, a former deputy director of advance operations for the Bush campaign and the Bush White House with no known previous experience in emergency management.
This is not the first administration to reward political loyalty with a job on the public payroll, but FEMA is an agency with life-saving responsibilities. It is no place for amateurs.
Bush has made an excellent choice in Paulison. Now, Bush and Chertoff should reconsider the decision to place FEMA within the Department of Homeland Security. Previously, it was an independent agency that enjoyed Cabinet status, a position that reflects its importance in times of natural disasters.
Ultimately, the point is not where FEMA fits into the organizational chart, but how it can be freed of limitations or restrictions that undermine the agency's ability to carry out its mission.
The task of fixing FEMA is urgent. September is normally the busiest month for hurricanes, and October is not far behind. The administration owes it to the public, especially to those who live in the most vulnerable regions of the country, to put the agency back in the hands of capable emergency-management professionals.
