What Islamic extremists call martyrdom is no such thing
A “martyrdom seekers” movement is growing in Iran. Recent reports suggest religious fanatics there have recruited 40,000 or more human time bombs, each ready to die to defend a perverted version of Islam.
We all know why this is scary. We see television footage of similar recruits from other countries killing innocent people by blowing themselves up in public places.
The more difficult question is why it’s wrong.
Martyrdom, after all, has a long and honored history in such religions as Judaism, Christianity, Islam and even Buddhism. What could be nobler than to resist — even unto death — efforts to get one to betray deeply held beliefs? Is this not standing up for truth as the resisters understand truth?
If we’re going to condemn Iran’s “martyrdom seekers” and others who are training to use themselves as self-destructive weapons — and, yes, we should condemn them — we should understand something of the history of martyrdom and why what Islamic extremists now call martyrdom is no such thing.
It is, rather, indefensible suicide and murder, and should be called that instead of martyrdom. It is offensive, not defensive, despite the phony rhetoric of defense attached to it by the cowardly clerics who urge others (but not themselves) to participate.
The Greek word at the root of martyrdom, “martys,” originally meant “witness,” and scholars say that is the sense in which it is often used in the New Testament. Because dying for one’s faith instead of denying it was the most dramatic witness one could make, the word martyr became closely associated with those who were put to death because of their religious beliefs. Notice again that I say they were put to death. They did not blow themselves up on crowded buses.
Martyrdom in early Judaism has many honored examples, including Daniel, who was thrown into a den of lions for his refusal to stop praying in a particular way. (The fact that the Bible says God “shut the mouth of the lions” and saved Daniel does not detract from his willingness to be martyred for his faith.)
One can argue about whether becoming a martyr by refusing to change religious practice or belief is always the wisest path. Wasn’t there another way to make the point and live to carry on for another day? Maybe. Maybe not. Hard to say from this vantage point. But the world’s religions have looked upon such martyrs (including, in Christianity, Jesus of Nazareth) as heroes and models of how to live out one’s values.
The 19 hijackers who committed the Sept. 11, 2001, attacks and the many suicide bombers who have died with praise to Allah on their lips did not act in the honored tradition of such martyrdom. Nor are Iran’s new recruits being asked to become traditional martyrs, despite their misappropriation of the term martyr. They are, rather, being recruited to be killers — of themselves and others.
The Middle East Media Research Institute, a non-profit group in Washington that follows press reports in the Arab world and beyond (including Iran), recently offered a compilation of reports about Iran’s martyrdom seekers that provide examples of what I mean.
First, it quoted a television interview in which the country’s newly elected president, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, said this: “Is there art that is more beautiful, more divine and more eternal than the art of martyrdom? . . . Have no doubt. . . . Allah willing, Islam will conquer what? It will conquer all the mountaintops of the world.”
Notice that this is recommending offensive — not defensive — operations.
Ahmadinejad’s spiritual leader, Ayatollah Mohammad Misbah Yazdi, also had some words to say about martyrdom: “Acts of martyrdom are the great pinnacle of the (Iranian) people and the height of its courage. . . .Our sacred organization (of “martyrdom seekers”) . . . is intended for those interested in carrying out shahada (martyrdom).”
Again, note that the goal is not defense but offense — “carrying out.” One of the Iranian martyrdom volunteers, by the way, said that the ayatollah told recruits this: “The gates of paradise have opened for you. There are beautiful black-eyed virgins waiting for you on the banks of rivers of honey.”
These religious wackos are giving martyrdom a bad name.
Bill Tammeus is a columnist for the Kansas City Star.
