OTHER VOICES
The best thing to come out of the Chinese offer to buy the U.S. oil company Unocal is a long overdue debate over whether China is friend or foe and what our policy toward it should be. The worst thing is that it has awakened fears bordering on xenophobia about the lurking Asian tiger that is ready to pounce on America and eat our lunch. Since when did making a bid to buy an American company become a virtual declaration of war?
China, it must be acknowledged, is not just another energy-hungry country. It is a communist dictatorship that encompasses the largest national population on the planet and has both the intention and the wherewithal to become a global military and economic power. It already is well on the way. The argument from those who see China primarily as a security threat is that we should not hasten the day when this Asian power becomes more dominant.
But sooner or later, with or without U.S. help, China will reach its potential. It is far preferable to improve our collaborative ties with China at this time and also deepen China's stake in the global economy, rather than turn a competitive relationship into a hostile confrontation.
For China, the search for energy resources is a national imperative. The last time a rising power in Asia sought more energy to fuel a military machine, pre-war Japan simply seized the resources from other countries in the region, precipitating World War II in the Pacific. China has chosen to make its challenge in economic terms, a far more preferable approach. Its leaders must be baffled to see this conventional capitalist tactic, a takeover bid, treated as a hostile attack by an enemy force.
If China is shut out of Western capital markets for energy companies, it can make deals with countries such as Sudan, Iran, Russia ... and Venezuela, whose President Hugo Chavez would love to find other markets besides the United States. How would it advance the U.S. national interest to have China develop closer economic ties to such countries instead of making deals with U.S. companies?
It is doubtful that U.S House of Representatives members considered this when they approved a resolution in June offered by Rep. Richard W. Pombo, R-Calif., which declared that allowing China to buy Unocal would "threaten to impair" U.S. national security. Incredibly, the resolution passed, 398-15, although it will have no effect in practical terms except to increase the mutual suspicion and hostility of the two countries.
Instead of windy resolutions, Congress - and the White House - should confront the real problems posed by China's rising power and its increasingly competitive disposition, beginning with the hunt for energy. Chinese oil demand now is second only to America's, and within 20 years it is expected to increase to 21 million barrels a day, roughly the level that America consumes today.
But instead of finding ways to make the United States less dependent on fossil fuel, Congress resists making tough calls such as raising the fuel efficiency of automobiles. This virtually guarantees an eventual confrontation not only with China but with India and other growing economies over energy resources.
As important, if not more, is U.S. dependency on China as a creditor. Thanks to all those cheap goods that China sells in this country, it has accumulated foreign-exchange reserves of nearly $750 billion, most of it in U.S. Treasury notes. China's willingness to keep on doing so keeps its workers employed - and assures political stability - but also keeps U.S. interest rates low. This frees up money for U.S. consumer spending, which buys more Chinese goods, which ... well, you get the picture. To make matters right, China must buy more from the United States, including - if that is their choice - second-tier oil companies such as the California-based Unocal.
The future of the U.S.-China relationship is not predestined. We can shape it and mold it in our interest by encouraging the growth of capitalism, or we can treat China only as a threat to national security. The former contains the promise of avoiding confrontation. The latter is almost surely a self-fulfilling prophecy.
