Roberts perhaps a pick too good to fight over
President Bush's nomination of John Roberts for a seat on the Supreme Court may have spoiled things for those spoiling for a fight. Judge Roberts is a good bet for confirmation. It may not even be close.
"There's no question about his legal skills, nor about his integrity," says Sen. Richard Durbin of Illinois, the Senate's second-ranking Democrat.
Having seen Roberts in action, I have to agree. Roberts was one attorney worth watching when he argued before the Supreme Court. Not because he was flamboyant, but because of his skill, preparation and measured demeanor. Roberts understands the court.
As well he should. He served as a clerk to Justice William Rehnquist (before Rehnquist became chief). As deputy solicitor general and as the head of law firm Hogan & Hartson's appellate practice, Roberts argued 39 cases before the court and won 25. That's major league.
Roberts has represented Chrysler Corp. and Toyota, coal companies, native Hawaiians and the National Collegiate Athletic Association. But those clients won't draw much attention in his confirmation hearings before the Senate Judiciary Committee.
The senators, at least the Democrats, will give thorough scrutiny to Roberts' record as an attorney and, for the past two years, as a judge on the U.S. Court of Appeals for the D.C. Circuit. But it will boil down to variations on three questions:
Is he conservative enough for Republicans?
Is he moderate enough for Democrats?
Will he vote to overturn Roe v. Wade and its guarantee of a woman's right to abortion?
Roberts knows the politics of this. At the end of the term in 2000, he reflected on the court's refusal to narrow abortion laws. It struck down a Nebraska ban of a late-term procedure described by opponents as "partial-birth abortion."
"It will, I think, be easier for conservatives to get particular interest groups, particular parts of the population out and vote by saying `look what the Supreme Court did in Stenberg,'" Roberts said.
The interest groups are already lined up for and against Roberts (you can check their Web sites yourself) over his statements about Roe. In one court brief for the solicitor general's office, he argued Roe has "no support in the text, structure or history of the Constitution." Yet in his confirmation hearings for the lower court, Roberts said, "Roe v. Wade is the settled law of the land," a legal precedent he could live with.
In his short term as a judge, Roberts has not yet been confronted with the abortion issue. That absence of a judicial paper trail befuddles those who are wary of where he might go as a justice.
"There are no flame-throwing articles or speeches, no judicial opinions that threaten established precedent, no visible hard edges," writes Linda Greenhouse, The New York Times' court-savvy reporter.
The word "precedent" is important. Stare decisis, in legal Latin, is revered by many justices. They do not lightly overturn the court's previous rulings. Roe has been law since 1973.
There is also a matter of numbers. The current court breaks 6-3, presumably in acceptance of Roe v. Wade. Justice Sandra Day O'Connor, whom Roberts would replace, is one of the six. Even if Roberts were to join the anti-Roe minority, the court would still be 5-4 for retaining the right to abortion. Justice Anthony Kennedy would replace O'Connor as the swing vote.
But we're not yet at the point of reversing Roe. Roberts' views on abortion could get an early test, though, as the court is scheduled to hear arguments next term in a New Hampshire case regarding parental notification before a minor could have an abortion.
A Supreme Court nominee typically, and correctly, refuses to tip his hand on any specific case. That may produce some huff and bluster from questioning Democrats. But don't expect Roberts' confirmation process to mirror the nastiness of Clarence Thomas' 1991 hearing, electrified by allegations of sexual harassment and counter-charges of racism. That ugly scene does not bear repeating.
Nor does President Bush want to repeat the experience of his father's other Supreme Court nominee. The elder Bush was assured he had a solid conservative in David Souter, also a jurist with little paper trail at the time of his nomination. Souter has for years sat comfortably among the court's liberals.
In selecting John Roberts, President Bush would seem to have avoided both pitfalls. Perhaps most important, by nearly all assessments, he's picked a stellar legal mind for the Supreme Court.
