Corporate directors still supporting CEOs, not shareholders
“Sinner on the mainland“He’s a sinner on the sea“He looks for absolution“Not accountability . . .“Remittance Man“Black sheep of the family clan . . .”So goes the Jimmy Buffett song. In the old days, the remittance man was the son who gambled, drank and womanized until his family paid him to go away.Now we have the 21st-century version — Philip Purcell, the former Morgan Stanley chief executive driven out last month after igniting a civil war at the securities firm. Earlier this month, we learned he’d been granted a $44 million “exit bonus” on top of $62 million in pension, stock options and other deferred compensation.Purcell ran off a string of executives in a dispute that drove the stock price down and finally embarrassed Morgan Stanley directors into dumping him and bringing back one of his predecessors. In this looking-glass world, it can pay to mess up.Years after Enron and all the other corporate scandals, we might have hoped directors would now be more careful with shareholders’ money.But the reforms of the past few years failed to end the tradition of mutual back-scratching between corporate directors and the executives they are supposed to oversee. At many companies, compensation for top executives continues to skyrocket.The biggest problem, of course, is that directors are too well insulated from shareholders. The directors themselves nominate candidates to replace any who leave, and they usually nominate just one per opening.Sometimes directors are recruited by the chief executives, and they often are very well paid. In setting executives’ pay, directors are not spending their own money. And, because many are executives themselves at other companies, they’re only too happy to contribute to the overall rise in executive pay.During his 28 months as chairman of the Securities and Exchange Commission, William Donaldson tried to tackle this problem by offering a measure to make it easier for shareholders to put up their own director candidates. But, faced with withering opposition from business groups, it went nowhere, and now the regulatory pendulum is poised to swing back to the conservative side.Donaldson stepped down June 30. To replace him, President Bush nominated conservative Republican Congressman Christopher Cox of California. In 1995, Cox was chief sponsor of a law making it harder for shareholders to sue companies and insulated executives from liability for bad accounting.An anti-regulatory shift will be even more likely at the SEC if Harvey Goldschmid, one of the two Democrats on the five-member commission, leaves this summer as expected. The two Democrats teamed with Donaldson, a moderate Republican, on many of the key market reforms of the past few years, such as a requirement that executive stock options be counted as a corporate expense, which would discourage their excessive use.What can shareholders do to keep directors on their side?Start by reading the annual reports and proxy materials that come before the annual meeting. Look, for example, at whether the top executive’s compensation is really tied to share-price gains or some other reasonable performance standard.Of course, you can write to the compensation committee or express your views in person at the annual meeting. And if you invest in stocks through mutual funds, you can urge fund managers to use their voting clout to press for shareholder-friendly behavior.SEC policies are set by the commissioners, who are nominated by the president and confirmed by the Senate. So your vote in the next national election will help determine corporate governance policy.If these suggestions seem like spitting into the wind, there’s a quick and sure way to deal with a company that misuses shareholders’ money:Sell the stock.
