Site last updated: Saturday, November 21, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

English's help needed to stop China from stealing Pa. jobs

Congressman Phil English is to be commended for his efforts to address the illegal trade practices that are destroying manufacturing in America and harming every community in Pennsylvania as more and more industries and family sustaining jobs are lost, especially to China.

Probably the single largest factor making U.S. products less-competitive against Chinese goods throughout the world is China's illegal manipulation of the value of its currency relative to the U.S. dollar.

According to the Economist magazine, this illegal practice gives Chinese goods an unfair price advantage of almost 60 percent over U.S.-manufactured goods in global markets, including the US.

This 60 percent "surcharge" the Chinese impose on our manufactured goods explains why the cost of finished goods from China is often cheaper than the cost of the raw materials needed to make the same products in the U.S.

Based on remarks Federal Reserve Chairman Alan Greenspan made at the Senate Finance Committee's U.S.-China Trade Relations hearing on June 23, he apparently does not consider this to be an important issue - even though it is leading directly to the China's stealing America's manufacturing base.

At this time, there are two bills before Congress that together provide companies that manufacture in the U.S. an effective legal remedy against injury caused by Chinese currency manipulation. They are:

The Stopping Overseas Subsidies Act (HR1216), introduced by Rep. English and Rep. Artur Davis (D-AL)

The China Currency Act of 2005 (HR1498), introduced by Rep. Tim Ryan (D-OH) and Rep. Duncan Hunter (R-CA).

The Hunter-Ryan bill would make currency manipulation an illegal export subsidy, so manufacturers could use our countervailing duty law to nullify the impact of this protectionist trade practice of the Chinese and other manipulators when applicable.

This legislation takes the Treasury Department out of the equation, and applies a rules-based remedy in the Commerce Department. (Treasury has demonstrated the unwillingness of both the Clinton and Bush administrations to deal effectively with Chinese currency manipulation.)

Rep. English has not yet elected to co-sponsor the Hunter-Ryan legislation, which is WTO compliant and has huge bipartisan support. Seven Pennsylvania congressional representatives including Melissa Hart, John Peterson, Jim Gerlach, Michael Fitzpatrick, Mike Doyle, Tim Holden and Todd Platts have already signed onto the bill.

Rep. English's staff has stated that he has no problem with the Hunter-Ryan bill and may support it if it comes to a vote. But that is not enough. We need Rep. English's active support so that it does come to a vote and passes.

Due to the soaring U.S. trade deficit with China, congressional representatives are hearing from small manufacturers throughout America,

Congress is in the mood to take some action on the China trade issue this year, especially relative to currency. However, when too many bills on an issue are introduced, confusion is created and Congress loses the political will to take effective action.

Several of the China bills recently introduced into Congress, including HR3005 (introduced by Rep. English), call for strong action on Chinese currency manipulation, but they are unlikely to be implemented because they violate our obligations under the WTO and are likely to be vetoed by the president.

Rep. English's leadership here can help to simplify the agenda and focus Congress on passing legislation that best addresses the currency issue.

Western Pennsylvania needs Rep. English to join with the rest of our region's congressional delegation to publicly support the Hunter-Ryan bill. This piece of legislation is very critical to the future of manufacturing and jobs in our area.

More in Other Voices

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS