Site last updated: Saturday, November 21, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Democrats need to turn 'no way' into new ideas

By CARL P. LEUBSDORF

Being a successful opposition party may be one of the toughest jobs in American politics.

It took Republicans years to figure it out. Now, the Democrats are having their own problems — at a time Americans have increasing doubts about President Bush and his key policies.

The result, so far, is a decidedly mixed record that provides little help for the Democrats’ uphill efforts to regain control of Congress in 2006.

The part they have mastered may be the least important aspect of opposition politics — getting media attention by bashing incumbents with flamboyant language.

National chairman Howard Dean has proved to be a master of invective. Senate Minority Leader Harry Reid has made his share of over-the-top comments. And Republicans forced his deputy, Illinois Sen. Dick Durbin, to apologize for likening U.S. treatment of prisoners in Cuba to tactics employed by Nazis and communists.

While such talk may fire up a party’s base, it also shifts public debate from GOP shortcomings to the impropriety of the comments.

The Democrats have done somewhat better in trying to keep Bush from enacting his proposals and installing the personnel to promote his long-term goals.

They have succeeded, with considerable GOP assistance, in making such a big issue of Bush’s unpopular plan for a private Social Security alternative that it now appears to be all but dead. They have succeeded in blocking some conservative federal appeals judges and regulators

The Democrats are doing the worst in the area that ultimately may be the most important, and that is to give voters an alternative to Mr. Bush’s vision on major issues — Social Security, the deficit and Iraq.

They need only to look back at the way Republicans waged the last successful takeover of Congress, in 1994, to recognize that beyond criticism, they must show how they would exercise authority.

Interestingly, in a recent CBS News-New York Times poll in which Bush fared poorly, two-thirds of those sampled said it was more important for Democrats to offer a Social Security alternative than to keep the current system.

Democratic leaders have been so fixated on defeating Bush that they not only haven’t offered their own proposals, but they have frowned on any Democrat who has done so.

As a result, the main alternatives floated to deal with Social Security’s long-term problems come from Republicans.

Sen. Lindsey Graham of South Carolina proposed raising the income level on which the payroll tax is levied, thereby increasing taxes for higher-income taxpayers.

Sen. Robert Bennett of Utah has proposed using current Social Security surpluses.

Sen. Chuck Hagel of Nebraska is among the Republicans on the Senate Finance Committee who have discussed raising the retirement age — now 65 but due to reach 67 by 2027 — to 68.

Undoubtedly, a factor in the Democrats’ reluctance to present alternatives is their fear of being labeled as tax-raisers. A similar concern may be keeping them from proposing significant measures to curb the deficit.

On Iraq, the party remains split. Those who opposed the president’s decision to overthrow Saddam Hussein maintain their all-out criticism or demand a schedule for U.S. withdrawal. Some who backed Bush are suggesting ways to make the U.S. effort more likely to succeed.

For example, Sen. Joseph Biden of Delaware, the top Democrat on the Foreign Relations Committee, urges the administration to seek more help from NATO allies to train Iraqi forces and patrol the Syrian border and to change the focus of its reconstruction aid to measures that will improve the everyday lives of Iraqis.

But for the most part, Democratic leaders have concentrated on bashing the premises under which Bush launched the war and his failure to stem the insurgency that has taken a mounting toll of Iraqi and U.S. lives.

Ultimately, the 2008 presidential campaign will prompt top Democrats to lay out an agenda.

In the meantime, party leaders seem content to hope the GOP will pay the price for the problems besetting Mr. Bush and his party’s failure to do much about them.

That may not be enough.

More in Other Voices

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS