Site last updated: Saturday, November 21, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

2-way hospital dialogue essential

It is disappointing that Joseph Stewart, chief executive officer of Butler Memorial Hospital, and John Righetti, the hospital's executive director of communications, chose to spend so much time writing opinion articles and spending money on television ads and direct mailings, rather than attend the recent community meeting and answer questions.

It appears they are adverse to a two-way dialogue. It seems they are comfortable only with one-way communication where they can control the audience and where they never have to answer directly and openly to all the public they serve.

John L. Wise III stated in a recent Butler Eagle editorial that the hospital has "mischaracterized," used "false arguments," "misleads," "been disingenuous," and "misrepresents the debate." He stated that hospital officials have taken the stance that if "you're not with us, you're the enemy."

We would like to emphasize that we are not against a new hospital. In fact, we strongly support the idea. The process and the lack of due diligence is our concern.

It makes absolutely no sense to build a smaller facility with fewer services, if more could be done on the current site for less money.

Here are a few of the indisputable facts:

The new hospital will be more than 100 beds smaller than the current facility. According to a chart presented by Stewart at a community meeting held in January 2004, there currently are 345 beds/bassinets at the hospital. Stewart and the Hammes report say the new hospital will have 220 beds.

The Hammes report allows for no psychiatry beds, nor a drug and alcohol rehabilitation unit (currently there are 59 beds for these services).

The Hammes report allows for no transitional-care beds (currently there are 25 beds).

The Hammes report states the historical rate of pay raises for employees will be less than in the past (Note to Butler Memorial staff: Your raises will be reduced to help fund the new, smaller hospital).

Because of these facts, there is concern about employee job losses with three floors of psychiatry closed, transitional care closed, half of obstetrics closed, and the loss of surgery to the new surgery center. Where are all of these employees and their support staffs going to work, with fewer services offered at Butler Memorial? How will the hundreds of U.S. Department of Veterans Affairs employees fit into this? Who will be laid off first?

The Butler Memorial administration states it is looking at alternatives to provide psychiatric and transitional care when the floors in question are closed. This sounds like administrative doublespeak for dumping on existing agencies such as the Irene Stacy Community Mental Health Center and Sunnyview Home. These agencies are already overburdened and underfunded.

The hospital administration also hints at piecemealing services in several different locations, which would be extremely inconvenient for patients. Replacing inpatient psychiatric beds with outpatient services is not the answer. Many psychiatric patients require inpatient care.

Other hospitals have realized that moving psychiatric patients away from the main hospital would stigmatize them and distance them from needed medical care. This preys on the most vulnerable in our community.

The Hammes report allows for no private medical/surgical beds, only ICU (intensive care), CCU (cardiac care) and OB (obstetrics). All of the rooms at the Kittanning and UPMC Franklin hospitals are private rooms. Private rooms provide improved patient care and a safer hospital environment with fewer medical errors. Before the new hospital is even built, Stewart and the board are compromising care to our community and to the veterans. What they are indicating is, unless you have a heart attack or have a baby, you will have a roommate.

The hospital's own architectural firm, RTKL of Dallas, in a board handout, stated: "The typical hospital project cost is $900,000 to $1.3 million per bed." Butler Memorial's proposed cost is set at $659,000 per bed. Butler Memorial's costs are so much lower because we are simply building a hospital with so much less in it. This type of low projection may result in large cost overruns or the project being scaled back even further.

When questioned at a hospital board of trustees meeting, none of the administrative team said they would agree to stay at Butler Memorial for 10 years to follow this project through to the end.

The cost of caring for seven veterans (the number of current inpatient beds at the Veterans Affairs Medical Center) for 75 years (the length of the land lease) had not been calculated before the vote on this project. At $1,000 a day per bed, that cost is $191.6 million, without inflation. Are 35 acres of leased (not owned) land worth more than $191 million?

The board voted to accept the Hammes report without reading it, and with only 10 minutes of discussion. The hospital paid $80,000 for this unread report. Board members know in their heart they did not read the report before voting. Is this proper due diligence? Please note that none of the administrators or board members have denied this fact in any of their mailings or TV ads.

The projected Blue Cross insurance increases for reimbursement are outlined in the Hammes report. Someone will pay for the increases - and that someone will be local employers and the community.

The Hammes Co. does not warrant or guarantee any of its financial projections. Why not? Is this because the projections are overly aggressive and likely unattainable?

According to the Hammes report, 40 more physicians need to be recruited to Butler Memorial in the next 10 years to pay for the new hospital, plus replace those who retire. With the malpractice climate in our state, this is highly unlikely to occur.

Donald Shamey, as chairman of board finance, at the public meeting in January 2004, said the hospital could not afford more than $150 million. He also said he would not vote for more than that.

He did.

We will have more than 100 fewer beds in the new hospital to take care of Butler County residents, neighboring county residents (part of the planned expansion of patients) and veterans. The "new type of bed" Stewart alludes to has never been defined. When you are sick, a bed is a bed.

The nursing staff has been quoted in the Butler Eagle regarding its dislike of the "bed shuffle" in the middle of the night, often because the rooms are mostly semi-private. Who gets what bed when the new Butler Memorial Hospital is full? Neither our veterans nor our residents should have to face this scenario because a smaller facility was built, without state-of-the-art, all-private rooms.

According to some in attendance at a recent private meeting, William Bessor, chairman of the hospital's board of trustees, repeatedly swore at Jack Beiler and James Eckstein, both of whom helped organize the most recent public meeting. If a hospital employee swore at anyone, would there be discipline rendered? What action, if any, has been taken by the board regarding this inappropriate and unprofessional behavior? The board's silence indicates that it condones the use of such offensive and obscene language. Is this the behavior we want representing this community on our hospital board? Do people of Butler County see why a community-elected board by a well-designed hospital association would be of value?

Minutes from the hospital board and medical staff meetings are edited by the administration. Controversies and discrepancies such as the closure of the Women's Surgery Center for half of the past year resulting in nursing reductions are prohibited or strongly discouraged from being written into the minutes. In our opinion, the current minutes are not fully reflective of what transpires at the meetings.

Executive salaries were never discussed in detail with the board. Even as board members, we first learned of the actual administrative salaries from the Butler Eagle.

The board was never told about the hospital's poor clinical ratings by healthgrades.com. We were only informed of the good ratings, but not areas that need improvement.

Board members were discouraged from attending finance committee meetings and were told by Shamey (chairman of finance and president of Citizens National Bank) that if they did, questions would not be permitted.

The hospital banking business was never put out for bid until this past year when it became public knowledge that Citizens National had the account without competitive bidding.

Citizens National Bank's competitor, Citizens Bank (Mellon), now known as Charter One, was excluded from the bidding process for the hospital business. Citizens National is in litigation with Citizens (Charter One). Trustee Magazine states, "Avoid trouble by prohibiting individuals with the most serious material conflicts from serving on the board, such as bankers."

Concerns of conflict of interest include the chairman of the board appointing his son-in-law to be a member of the board. Trustee Magazine: "Nepotism is a conflict of interest on boards involving favoritism shown to relatives, friends or associates."

The intent of the board, term limits of nine or 12 years, have not been followed. By "changing" the bylaws, some members have been on the board for 20 years. This bypasses the goal of term limits to provide fresh insight and ideas on the board.

These are just a few of the facts that deeply concern this community. The public forum was an opportunity for the board to face these facts and explain its decisions that will affect our community's health care for the next generation.

As Wise said in his editorial, had the board and administration come to the public meeting, they would have found an audience that "maintained an air of professionalism throughout the evening," who simply wanted to dialogue with those who run our hospital.

It is indeed disappointing they chose not to come and, instead, sent their attorney.

It is also sad to put the community, patients, medical staff and the employees in this crossfire that affects all of us. We genuinely feel empathy for the employees who work so hard to give our community the best care possible.

Many employees have spoken with us, expressing their disagreement with the administration's plans. They have spoken of their inability to speak candidly because of fear of retribution.

We agree that a new hospital tower is necessary. Simply put, why build a smaller hospital with fewer services when you can potentially do more on the current site for less money?

Common sense calls for a study that is without preconceived restrictions to get the result that the administration wants. Some of the most advanced health care in the nation is in cities with much less land than Butler Memorial Hospital has. They continue to rebuild and stay on the cutting edge of technology.

It is clear that the Butler Memorial board does not have enough money to replace our current hospital. That is why the proposed new hospital is smaller, with fewer services, and not state-of-the-art with all private rooms.

Unfortunately, it seems as though the board and administration have dug their heels in and have let egos get in the way of common sense and what is best for the community.

The current issue of Trustee Magazine says, "Making hospital information easily accessible to the public is the only way for hospitals to maintain the public's trust." The lack of trust persists here because the board is insisting on controlling the one-way dissemination of information.

Such a tight grip is perceived by many in the community as contrary to the public's best interests.

As John Wise's editorial said, only the board can heal this lack of trust.

Joan Chew and Dr. Ronald Cypher are former members of the Butler Memorial Hospital Board of Trustees.

More in Other Voices

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS