Site last updated: Saturday, October 10, 2026

Log In

Reset Password
Butler County's great daily newspaper

Anglers getting hooked on Lake Erie steelhead

NORTH EAST, Pa. - Steve Young loves all things fish, but he loves steelhead in particular.

So much so that he quit his job as a motorcycle salesman several years ago to guide anglers visiting Lake Erie's tributary waters during the fall and winter steelhead runs.

Consider him just one example of a $9.5 million-a-year steelhead industry in Erie County, as a recent Pennsylvania Fish and Boat Commission study found. The financial impact quadrupled in 20 years.

That's a stunning number, considering Pennsylvania has about only 60 miles of coastline on Lake Erie and about a dozen fishable tributaries. Steelhead can also be caught in the lake.

Alaskan and Pacific Northwestern rivers have long enjoyed reputations as steelhead destinations, but over the past decade, the Great Lakes' steelhead fishery is becoming better known.

"I think it ranks with any fishing place in the world," said Young, 55, of Wexford. "The advantage of the Pennsylvania streams that attract all the fishermen is that it's sight-fishing. The clarity, that's what really thrills people."

Even on a recent rainy day when the water in one tributary was up, many of the behemoths could be seen holding in pools. As big as steelhead are - two-footers are common - it can take a while to train the eye to spot their camouflaged form (tip: look for movement, not an entire fish). Then, they're seemingly everywhere.

Steelhead are rainbow trout that spend much of their adult lives in the ocean or large lakes. They swim into freshwater to spawn and, unlike salmon, can spawn more than once before they die. Anglers pursue what many consider to be freshwater's most prized games with flies, bait and lures.

The entire month of November is prime steelhead time, though they make spawning runs from fall to spring.

"I think people think of Thanksgiving as opening day," Young said. There are so many people on the streams, he won't take anyone out that entire week.

But Young and others lament the fishery might be getting too popular. He's strictly catch-and-release, believing the fish are resources best left for another day. Nearly 80 percent of anglers release their catch, the study found.

With the increasing number of anglers seeking steelhead come problems of access. Some landowners have posted their land, reducing access to the waters.

One landowner did so after an angler relieved himself on the property on a recent Thanksgiving Day, in view of the family as they ate, said Tom Cooper, who runs North Fork Flies, an online fly fishing shop in suburban Pittsburgh.

"They have no respect for the private owner," Cooper said of inconsiderate anglers.

Gary Heubel is president of the Pennsylvania Steelhead Association and owner of Poor Richard's Bait and Tackles shops in the Erie County towns of Fairview and North East. He agrees that an increasing amount of private land is getting posted.

"We need to compensate the landowners in some way for all the money coming into this area," Heubel said. He favors some type of tax break for property owners who grant land easements.

"If we can't fish for them, we're going to lose (the fishery)," he said. "Just as fast as it's exploding, it's imploding."

On a recent outing, although Cooper failed to land a steelhead in several hours' fishing, he did catch a large brown trout. He also spent a good amount of time watching a newcomer get the hang of fighting a large steelhead.

While there's no guarantee of catching a steelhead, the catch rate on Erie tributaries is still high. The study found that more than a half-million steelhead are caught each year, with the average angler catching a steelhead about every 90 minutes.

"Out West, the fish are bigger, but out there, you catch two, three fish a day and that's a good day," Heubel said. "But for sheer numbers, Pennsylvania steelhead is the best place in the world. Around here, guys that fish all the time, they'll catch, 20, 30, a day."

OUTDOORS INFO


Hunters and anglers seeking information about licenses, seasons and bag limits can find it at the Pennsylvania Game Commission web site at www.pgc.state.pa.us and the Fish and Boat Commission site at www.fish.state.pa.us

More in Outdoor

Subscribe to our Daily Newsletter

* indicates required
TODAY'S PHOTOS