Reunion small, but warm
The buzz last weekend at the 60th reunion for the Butler High School Class of 1944 was over which class those in attendance really graduated from.
In 1944, Butler High School graduated two classes: one in January, the other in June.
The former students weren't sure why there were two classes, but Henrietta LaBernz Pigg, a June graduate, thought the tradition of having two classes started years before.
"It probably started with the much earlier years, when we skipped people in elementary," she said. "If they skipped a half year in elementary, then they would graduate in January."
Dick Dougan, a January graduate, thought it was a trial program the Butler school system was researching.
"I think it was an experiment, to tell you the truth," he said.
Dougan recalled that Butler graduated two classes a year from 1930 to 1950.
"I never saw it anywhere else," he said.
Whatever the circumstances, the grads from the two classes of 1944 mingled with each other without bias toward classmates from their own graduation month. They chatted congenially, shared stories, and enjoyed memories of yesteryear.
Of 446 graduates, 157 have died.
"That's 35 percent," said Robert Somerville, a June graduate and one of the organizers of the reunion. He remembered a few died in World War II.
Dougan remembered he and the young men with whom he graduated proudly served their country.
"I enlisted at 17," he said. "Most of our people were ready to go."
His friend and fellow graduate, Dick Baumgarten, enlisted too.
"It's amazing," Baumgarten said, "We were afraid the war would be over (before we got to go serve)."
They remembered one classmate who died in July 1944, barely out of boot camp.
"It's the American military blood that makes payment on our freedom," Dougan said. "Everybody's had a lot happen in 60 years."
Pigg agreed that a lot has happened over the past years. She spent the evening reminiscing about all her classmates.
"I'm just remembering people here," she said. "They look a lot different!"
Dottie Kennedy, a June graduate, agreed that people's looks had changed, but she didn't think of it as a bad thing.
"I was just an average student who just squeaked by," she said, "I had my eye on the guys!" There was one handsome boy she particularly remembered. "Of course I never was lucky enough to go on a date with him." She pointed across the room to where he sat chatting. "He's still pretty cute," she said smiling.
Jane Kummer, January grad, also had her eye on the boys. She remembered liking to be at the school before the bell signaled time to begin the day.
"What I really do remember the most was walking the halls before the bell rang," she said. "This is like before school starts."
She and her friends would walk around the first floor, two or three abreast.
"It was kind of scouting time, and when the bell rang, everybody just ran. Those were fun days. We knew everybody," she said.
Dorothy Keasey Klaczak, a June graduate, liked supporting the football team. So did Beryl Curry Tait, a 1945 graduate, spouse of one of the 1944 classmates in attendance, and Klaczak's friend since 1940.
"Our teams during the war," Klaczak said, "we were bad."
The team may have suffered from poor statistics, but Klaczak's memories of the ball games are good ones.
"I was a twirler (for the band)," she said.
So was Tait. "I got my letter," she said.
"I did too," Klaczak remembered. "I got my sweater (too)."
The two friends enjoyed going to the games but there weren't many out of town they were able to attend.
"We were in the war years. We didn't go very far. No gas. No tires," she said.
Tait agreed. "We'd all pile in an old car and have eleven flat tires before we got to the Boy Scout camp on Route 8 North," Tait said.
For one, this reunion represented the first time he had seen his former classmates since early in his high school career. Ivan Novick was extremely happy to be in attendance. This year was the first he'd been invited to any of the reunions.
"They found me after 60 years," he said.
Novick moved away in the 10th grade and until recently, nobody knew where he was, although he had only gone to Chambersburg.
Helen and Tony Cehelsky were happy to be there too. "We like to meet the people," Helen Cehelsky said.
"I wonder how many of these people we will know, or who will know us," Tony Cehelsky said.
At the last reunion they attended, they chatted with a classmate they were happy to connect with after many years. A week later, that classmate died. The Cehelskys realized fewer classmates will be able to attend the reunions.
Verna Mae Iman agreed.
"The reason I came this time," she said, "they said it would be the last one."
According to Joan Gregg, who has helped organize the reunions since the beginning, "The people in Butler do not come."
Classmates came from California, Washington, Florida, Texas, Arizona, Kansas, Illinois, New York, and Virginia. Some drove four hours to spend the weekend.
But many of the graduates living close by chose not to participate in the event. Only 70 classmates - 15 percent - showed up for the weekend's festivities.
Iman has just two words to say to those graduates living close enough yet choosing not to attend, "Shame, shame!" she said.
