Growth has public housing under review
DETROIT - These days, when as many tricycles as walkers litter the hallways of many senior living centers, cities are trying to figure out the best way to accommodate - under one roof - grandparents and the children they are raising.
The results are new homes with services and features for all members of the so-called "grandfamilies." There's day care for the children and windows that look out over the playground so the grandparents can watch from inside.
Developers in Detroit are planning two projects of specially designed low-income housing. Similar projects already exist in Boston and Buffalo, N.Y., while Chicago and New York City have broken ground on their own developments.
"The dynamics of families are changing, and we need to figure out new ways to address it so these children can grow up whole," said Sharon West, director of the Buffalo Municipal Housing Authority and a 56-year-old grandmother who is raising her 6-year-old granddaughter.
Other cities with plans for grandfamily housing include Baltimore; New Haven, Conn.; Cleveland; Detroit; Philadelphia; Phoenix; Oklahoma City; Trenton, N.J.; Nashville, Tenn.; Sacramento, Calif.; and Tacoma, Wash.
Subsidized townhouses planned for Detroit will create a community cluster of practical, attractive and safe homes for grandparents 55 and older thrust back into parenthood.
They will be in working-class neighborhoods, bounded by fences and hedges, and will include a library, computer room, classroom and recreation center, among other built-in conveniences.
"The apartments in Boston, for example, are built for both age groups, so that you have grab bars in the bathrooms, and covers for the electrical outlets," said Donna Butts, executive director of Generations United, a nationwide advocacy group for grandparents.
The housing options are filling a much-needed void. U.S. Census figures show that roughly 2.4 million grandparents nationwide in 2002 were raising their grandchildren, up from about a million in 1990.
Millie Stewart joined those ranks nearly two years ago when her daughter's mental illness prevented her from caring for her three children, ages 16, 14 and 6.
The 64-year-old retired IRS pay clerk could get by on her pension and Social Security when it was just her, but is stretching her budget to the limits now - driving without car insurance, borrowing to pay for gas and racking up credit card bills.
She had to get a bigger home, and her rent doubled to $500 a month. Cleaning, caring for the children, taking them to school and the dentist, going to the supermarket and cooking meals leaves her too exhausted even to think about getting a job.
"It's hard. It's a struggle," Stewart said. "But how do you tell your grandkids you can't take care of them because you can't afford it? You can't say that."
For Stewart, the proposed grandfamily developments are appealing because of their affordability and the prospect of neighbors who could provide a support system, baby sitters and playmates for her grandchildren.
Stewart's granddaughter, 16-year-old Shana Burden, wishes her grandma's Detroit neighborhood had teenagers in it, but says living there has brought structure to her life and the lives of her siblings.
They do chores, clean the house, go to school every day, go to bed on time. Their grades have improved, and they find they actually are allowed to spend more time talking on the phone with their friends.
In Detroit, one proposed development, on the city's southwestern side, would have 11 townhouses; the other, on the east side, would have up to 16 units for grandparents raising disabled grandchildren.
Groups behind both projects say they need to keep the size of the complexes manageable and want to avoid high-rise projects that have marked the skylines of many inner cities. Rent for a four-bedroom home would run about $350 to $700 a month.
The nonprofit groups behind both projects, Bridging Communities and Church of the Messiah Housing Corp., plan to apply next month for grants from city and state housing authorities. They hope federal tax credits will fund the largest share of the projects, which could be completed in late 2005.
Miguel Caballero, who helps Buffalo residents in intergenerational and mixed-family housing, said such developments help support families that otherwise might not be able to make it.
"People respond to their environments," he said, "and if you give them a place that they want to have a stake in, then they will do well."
