Marketplace   Menu Guide   Complete Pages      
butler eagle
Site last updated: Thursday, August 21, 2014 Bookmark our site!
Local PennsylvaniaNationalInternationalNews Extras  
Published: February 13, 2013 print this article Print save this article Save email this article Email ENLARGE TEXT increase font decrease font

Militia Act not first

Rick Devore’s Jan. 28 letter to the editor, “Ignore gun propaganda,” says the Second Amendment phrase “a well-regulated militia” has to do with the right of the government to call up a militia. He uses the example of the Militia Act of 1792 being the basis for quelling the Whiskey Rebellion.
The Constitution was adopted in 1787, and the Bill of Rights, which contains the Second Amendment, was ratified in 1791.
The Militia Act was based on the Second Amendment, which was written first. Since the Second Amendment was written first, Devore doesn’t have a premise on which to build his argument.
Also, would quelling of the Whiskey Rebellion have been successful if George Washington would have had to train and arm every man of that militia? What if they hadn’t had their guns? What if they weren’t trained? The Whiskey Rebellion’s outcome would have been different.
Washington was well aware that everyone he called up would have an arm and be able to use it.
What if our citizens don’t have guns and a foreign power invades us? By the time we could re-arm and train them, we would be at the mercy of the foreign invader or yes, perhaps, our own tyrannical government, if that would be the case.
Devore’s letter gives the false impression or interpretation that all terms of the Militia Act are the final say, when it was the Constitution that was written first and supersedes, overpowers and overreaches the Militia Act.




Rebecca Allison
Donegal Township
Back
 
Comments
Order Photos!
 
MORE LETTERS TO THE EDITOR HEADLINES
arrow Livestock donated
arrow Pool benefits limited
arrow How many supervisors
 
MOST READ ARTICLES
arrow Fatal crash caused by driver running red light
arrow At least 1 injured in 2-car crash on Rt. 8 at Clearview Mall
arrow Coroner’s office investigates crash death of Cranberry Township woman
arrow Police: Fatal accident could have been caused by medical condition